工具性支持电话与关怀联系短信预防青少年及成人自杀:SPARC随机临床试验
SPARC实用性比较效果随机试验将9家急诊和36家基层诊所筛出的12-17岁青少年(N=723)和18岁以上成人(N=797)按1:1随机分入工具性支持电话(ISC)或双向关怀联系短信(CC)组。6个月时成人CC组自杀意念/行为评分显著高于ISC组,12个月时青少年CC组评分显著低于ISC组。提示最佳自杀预防随访方式可能因年龄而异。
要点
- 成人6个月时CC组自杀意念/行为评分显著高于ISC组(ADM=0.50,95%CI=0.12,0.88)。
- 青少年12个月时CC组评分显著低于ISC组(ADM=-0.64,95%CI=-1.11,-0.18)。
- 青少年6个月及成人12个月时两组结局相似,随访方式的最佳选择可能因年龄而异。
核心结论
- 最佳自杀预防随访照护可能因年龄而异:青少年可能更受益于较长程、以连接为核心的双向关怀联系短信,成人可能更受益于更密集的早期工具性支持电话。
研究设计与样本
- SPARC为实用性比较效果随机临床试验,按年龄分层,参与者按1:1随机分入ISC或CC组。
- 参与者为2021年5月至2022年7月在9家急诊和36家基层诊所筛查出自杀风险的12-17岁青少年(N=723)和18岁以上成人(N=797),主要数据收集于2023年8月完成。
- 主要结局为6个月时哥伦比亚自杀严重程度评定量表自杀意念/行为评分,12个月时为次要结局。
主要发现
- 青少年N=723,平均年龄14.9岁(SD=1.6),女性75%,白人84.1%,非西班牙裔84.2%。
- 成人N=797,平均年龄38.3岁(SD=15.9),女性70%,白人89.1%,非西班牙裔90%。
- 6个月时青少年两组结局相似,成人CC组自杀意念/行为评分显著高于ISC组(ADM=0.50,95%CI=0.12,0.88)。
- 12个月时青少年CC组评分显著低于ISC组(ADM=-0.64,95%CI=-1.11,-0.18),成人两组结局相似。
临床怎么用
- 对成人自杀风险患者,早期可优先考虑工具性支持电话等较密集的主动支持随访。
- 对青少年自杀风险患者,较长程的双向关怀联系短信可能更有利于12个月时的结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The authors sought to determine whether augmenting usual suicide care with follow-up in the form of instrumental support calls (ISC) or two-way Caring Contacts texts (CC) works best to reduce suicidal ideation and behavior (SI/SB) in adolescents and adults. METHODS: The Suicide Prevention Among Recipients of Care (SPARC) Trial is a pragmatic comparative effectiveness randomized clinical trial stratified by age, with participants randomized in a 1:1 ratio to ISC or CC. Participants were adolescents (12-17 years, N=723) and adults (18+ years, N=797) who screened at risk for suicide in emergency departments (N=9) and primary care clinics (N=36) between May 2021 and July 2022; primary data collection was completed in August 2023. Outcomes included Columbia-Suicide Severity Rating Scale SI/SB score at 6 months (primary) and 12 months (secondary). RESULTS: Adolescents (N=723; mean age, 14.9 years [SD=1.6]) were mostly female (75%), White (84.1%), and non-Hispanic (84.2%). Adults (N=797; mean age, 38.3 years [SD=15.9]) were mostly female (70%), White (89.1%), and non-Hispanic (90%). At 6 months, outcomes were similar by condition among adolescents, but among adults, SI/SB scores were significantly higher among those receiving CC compared to those receiving ISC (adjusted difference in means [ADM]=0.50, 95% CI=0.12, 0.88). At 12 months, adolescents' SI/SB scores were significantly lower in the CC compared with the ISC condition (ADM=-0.64, 95% CI=-1.11, -0.18), but outcomes were similar by condition among adults. CONCLUSIONS: The best suicide prevention follow-up care may vary by age, with adolescents benefiting most from longer-term connection-focused two-way CC and adults benefiting most from more intensive early instrumental support through ISC.
引用
- Radin AK, Shaw J, Brown SP, et al. Instrumental Support Calls vs. Caring Contacts Texts to Prevent Suicide in Adolescents and Adults: The SPARC Randomized Clinical Trial. Am J Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 42946687. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.20260157
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。