文献速递精神分裂症与精神病性障碍会诊联络精神医学

挪威强制精神卫生保健人群的长期健康、刑事司法和社会经济结局:全国注册队列研究

Long-term health, criminal justice, and socioeconomic outcomes among people subject to compulsory mental health care in Norway: a nationwide registry cohort study.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Psychiatry · 2026-01-01

该研究基于挪威全国注册数据,比较2015-2016年接受社区治疗令、强制住院、强制观察、自愿精神卫生保健及一般人群的18-65岁个体至2021-23年的长期结局。结果显示强制保健组在健康、刑事司法和社会经济领域的结局显著差于自愿患者和一般人群,且不同强制保健组预后不同,女性自伤或自杀概率较高而男性物质使用障碍及暴力或性犯罪指控概率较高。

要点

  • 强制保健组长期健康、刑事司法和社会经济结局显著差于自愿患者和一般人群。
  • 强制观察组自伤或自杀及物质使用障碍调整概率在五组中最高。
  • 社区治疗令组残疾福利领取调整概率最高,女性89%、男性93%。

核心结论

  • 强制保健组与自愿保健组和一般人群具有不同的长期预后。
  • 法律定义的强制保健组不应被视为单一预后人群。

研究设计与样本

  • 全国注册队列研究,纳入2015年1月1日至2016年12月31日挪威18-65岁有专科精神卫生保健接触者及按年龄性别抽样的普通人群对照。
  • 随访至2021-23年,依据注册数据可及性;采用分离二项回归估计按性别分组的调整概率,调整出生年份。
  • 有精神卫生服务亲身经历者参与研究设计和解释。

主要发现

  • 强制保健组在健康、刑事司法和社会经济领域的长期结局显著差于自愿患者和一般人群。
  • 强制保健组中,女性自伤或自杀调整概率高于男性,而男性物质使用障碍及因暴力或性犯罪被指控或监禁的调整概率高于女性。
  • 强制观察组自伤或自杀及物质使用障碍调整概率在五组中最高。

临床怎么用

  • 强制保健组应作为不同预后人群分别评估和管理,而非单一群体。
  • 这些人群水平基准可用于服务规划和政策评估。

局限性

  • 种族数据不可用。
  • 随访截止时间因注册数据可及性而异(2021-23年)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Compulsory mental health care aims to manage risk and treatment needs among people with severe mental illness, but evidence on long-term outcomes across health, justice, and socioeconomic domains is scarce. We aimed to compare long-term outcomes across adult groups defined by community treatment orders (CTOs), compulsory hospitalisation, compulsory observation, and voluntary mental health care, and the general population. METHODS: In this nationwide registry cohort study, we identified all individuals aged 18-65 years with specialist mental health-care contact in Norway from Jan 1, 2015, to Dec 31, 2016 and general population comparators sampled via Statistics Norway based on age and sex. Follow-up was through 2021-23, depending on registry availability. Study groups were defined hierarchically: CTO, compulsory hospitalisation without CTO, compulsory observation without compulsory hospitalisation or CTO, voluntary mental health care, and no specialist mental health-care contact (ie, the general population). Outcomes included mortality and cause of death, self-harm treated in emergency departments or hospital, substance use disorder, victimisation, violent or sexual offence charges or imprisonment, subsequent compulsory care, acute admissions, and socioeconomic outcomes. Data for all groups were sourced from linked nationwide registries. Separate binomial regressions estimated sex-specific probabilities by group, adjusting for birth year. People with lived experience of mental health services advised study design and interpretation. FINDINGS: The final study sample comprised 321 708 individuals (mean age 36·5 years, range 18-65) across five mutually exclusive groups: CTO (n=3331), compulsory hospitalisation (n=2907), compulsory observation (n=2554), voluntary care (n=177 396), and general population (n=135 520), 193 473 (60·1%) were female and 128 235 (39·9%) were male; ethnicity data were unavailable. Compulsory care groups were associated with substantially worse long-term outcomes across health, criminal justice, and socioeconomic domains than voluntary patients and the general population. Across compulsory care groups, female participants had higher adjusted probabilities of self-harm or suicide than male participants, whereas male participants had higher adjusted probabilities of substance use disorder and of being charged with or imprisoned for violent or sexual offences compared with female participants. The compulsory observation group had the highest adjusted probabilities of self-harm or suicide and substance use disorder across the five groups. Self-harm or suicide was recorded in 135 (12·1%) of 1115 female participants (adjusted probability 12% [95% CI 10-14]) and 75 (5·7%) of 1308 male participants (5·5% [4·4-6·9]). Substance use disorder was recorded in 407 (39·1%) of 1041 female participants (39% [36-42]) and 639 (53·2%) of 1202 male participants (53% [50-56]). Charges or imprisonment for violent or sexual offences were recorded in 146 (14·2%) of 1030 female participants (14% [12-16]) and 446 (37·4% [34-40]) of 1194 male participants. During 2015-21, including the inclusion period, suicide and other external causes accounted for 132 (55·7%) of 237 classified deaths in compulsory observation, compared with 1818 (38·2%) of 4754 in voluntary care and 174 (18·6%) of 938 in the general population. The CTO group had the highest adjusted probability of disability benefit receipt: 89% (95% CI 87-91) in female participants and 93% (92-94) in male participants; a substantial minority of disability-benefit recipients in the CTO group also had earned income. INTERPRETATION: Compulsory care groups were associated with distinct long-term prognoses from the voluntary care and general population groups. These findings provide population-level benchmarks for service planning and policy evaluation and show that legally defined compulsory care groups should not be treated as a single prognostic population. FUNDING: Research Council of Norway.

来源:Lancet Psychiatry,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hofstad T, Nyttingnes O, Blindheim AA, et al. Long-term health, criminal justice, and socioeconomic outcomes among people subject to compulsory mental health care in Norway: a nationwide registry cohort study. Lancet Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 42874602. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(26)00275-0

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。