文献速递儿童青少年精神

精神疾病分类学的概念挑战:跨越六版DSM的ADHD诊断演变

Conceptual challenges in psychiatric nosology: ADHD across six editions of the DSM.
PubMed 文献 · Br J Psychiatry · 2026-09-07

本文基于对DSM-III(1980)至DSM-5-TR(2022)中所有ADHD相关描述的系統性文本分析,从科学哲学原理出发,考察ADHD诊断修订中出现的五个关键分类挑战:患病率与偏离阈值、性别与诊断异质性、病因学框架与解释连贯性、医学框架与诊断边界、共病与判别效度,并讨论这些挑战对精神疾病诊断结构和概念一致性的广泛启示。

要点

  • ADHD诊断标准历经六版DSM修订,五个分类挑战持续存在且相互关联
  • 患病率与偏离阈值、性别与诊断异质性是核心分类难题
  • 病因学框架、医学框架与共病问题影响诊断边界和判别效度

核心结论

  • ADHD诊断修订中出现的五个分类挑战反映了精神疾病分类学中缺乏清晰生物标志物、疾病内高异质性和疾病间高共病等持久难题。
  • 应对这些挑战及精神疾病诊断的更广泛认识论基础,可能有助于临床医生在日常实践中处理复杂诊断决策,并帮助理论家开发未来的精神疾病分类系统。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为理论分析,锚定于先前对DSM-III(1980)至DSM-5-TR(2022)中所有ADHD相关描述的系统性文本分析的实证发现。
  • 分析借鉴科学哲学的基础原理,考察针对实证发现或临床关切引入的诊断调整对精神疾病诊断的结构、边界和概念一致性可能产生的广泛影响。

主要发现

  • 分析识别出五个关键分类挑战:(a)患病率与偏离阈值;(b)性别与诊断异质性;(c)病因学框架与解释连贯性;(d)医学框架与诊断边界;(e)共病与判别效度。

临床怎么用

  • 应对这些分类挑战及精神疾病诊断的更广泛认识论基础,可能有助于临床医生在日常实践中处理复杂诊断决策。
  • 该分析也可能帮助理论家开发未来的精神疾病分类系统。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Recent initiatives by the American Psychiatric Association to revise the DSM reflect renewed efforts to address enduring challenges in psychiatric nosology (e.g. absence of clear biological markers, substantial heterogeneity within disorders and high comorbidity across disorders). This article examines five key classification challenges emerging from successive diagnostic revisions in one of the most common childhood diagnoses: attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Importantly, this theoretical analysis is anchored in prior empirical findings from a systematic textual analysis of all DSM descriptions related to ADHD, from DSM-III (1980) to DSM-5-TR (2022). Drawing on foundational principles from the philosophy of science, the analysis examines how diagnostic adjustments introduced in response to empirical findings or clinical concerns may carry broader implications for the structure, boundaries and conceptual coherence of psychiatric diagnosis. These include: (a) prevalence and the threshold of deviance; (b) gender and diagnostic heterogeneity; (c) aetiological framing and explanatory coherence; (d) medical framing and diagnostic boundaries; and (e) comorbidity and discriminant validity. Addressing these challenges, as well as the broader epistemic foundations of psychiatric diagnosis discussed in this article, may benefit clinicians facing complex diagnostic decisions in everyday practice and theorists developing future psychiatric classification systems.

来源:Br J Psychiatry,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ophir Y. Conceptual challenges in psychiatric nosology: ADHD across six editions of the DSM. Br J Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 42702794. doi:10.1192/bjp.2026.10768

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。