精神病性障碍罕见病因诊断技术临床应用的伦理问题
本文从精神科、神经科、哲学、神经科学、社会学和医学伦理学的多学科视角,识别了使用腰椎穿刺、特殊脑成像和基因检测等诊断技术查找精神病性障碍罕见病因时出现的伦理问题,将其归为诊断公正、道德责任和诊断检查的意外后果三类,并讨论了未解决问题与未来方向。
要点
- 诊断公正挑战涉及「运气」、社会资本和既往精神科诊断对获得检查机会的影响。
- 道德责任挑战涉及临床医生对罕见或超罕见病因预警信号和检查的了解程度,以及卫生系统管理者应使有知识的临床医生能够提供必要检查。
- 意外后果挑战包括追求罕见病因检查可能强化精神科例外主义和不允许患者偏好的家长式决策。
核心结论
- 使用腰椎穿刺、特殊脑成像和基因检测等诊断技术查找精神病性障碍罕见病因的当前临床实践引发了多个具有挑战性的伦理问题。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为多学科视角的分析文章,作者来自精神病学、神经病学、哲学、神经科学、社会学和医学伦理学,来自三个国家。
主要发现
- 诊断公正挑战围绕「运气」、社会资本和既往精神科诊断在决定获得检查机会中的作用。
- 道德责任挑战围绕临床医生被期望了解罕见或超罕见病因的预警信号和检查的程度,以及卫生系统管理者应使有知识的临床医生能够提供必要检查。
- 意外后果挑战包括追求罕见病因检查以强化精神科例外主义和不允许患者偏好的家长式决策的风险。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
An estimated 5% of cases of first-episode psychosis are due to rare and sometimes reversible causes that can be identified through diagnostic investigations that are currently less common in psychiatry, e.g. lumbar puncture, specialised brain imaging and genetic testing. The current clinical practice of the use of such technologies, however, raises several challenging ethical questions. Drawing on our multidisciplinary perspective spanning psychiatry, neurology, philosophy, neuroscience, sociology and medical ethics from three countries, we identify emerging ethical issues in the diagnosis of rare causes of psychosis. We group challenges thus: (a) diagnostic justice, (b) moral responsibility and (c) unintended consequences of diagnostic work-up. Justice challenges surrounded the role of (a) 'luck', (b) social capital and (c) prior psychiatric diagnoses in determining access to work-up. Moral responsibility challenges surround the extent to which (a) clinicians are expected to know the red flags and work-up for rare or ultra-rare causes; and (b) those running health systems should enable knowledgeable clinicians to provide the requisite work-up. Challenges related to unintended consequences include the risk of pursuing work-up of rare causes to reinforce (a) psychiatric exceptionalism and (b) paternalistic decision-making that doesn't allow space for patient preferences. Finally, we reflect on unresolved issues and future directions.
引用
- Baum ML, Blackman G, Al-Diwani A, et al. Ethical issues in the clinical use of diagnostic technologies for rare causes of psychosis. Br J Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 42299629. doi:10.1192/bjp.2026.10675
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。