惊恐障碍的结构性脑差异:ENIGMA焦虑工作组4924人全球大样本分析
该研究基于ENIGMA焦虑工作组的多中心神经影像数据库,比较了1146例惊恐障碍患者与3778名健康对照的皮层和皮层下结构差异。结果显示患者额-颞-顶叶区域皮层厚度更薄、表面积更小,丘脑和尾状核体积更小,且存在诊断与年龄的交互效应,早发患者侧脑室更大。
要点
- 惊恐障碍患者存在额-颞-顶叶皮层厚度变薄和表面积减小,以及丘脑和尾状核体积减小。
- 诊断与年龄的交互效应显示成年期(25-55岁)患者皮层厚度低于对照,青年和晚年差异不明显。
- 早发惊恐障碍(≤21岁)与侧脑室增大相关,未发现用药、共病或严重程度效应。
核心结论
- 惊恐障碍患者存在额-纹状体-边缘环路及颞-顶叶区域的结构性脑差异,支持相关神经环路模型。
- 异常发育和衰老可能在惊恐障碍相关神经解剖差异中具有潜在重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 基于ENIGMA焦虑工作组多中心神经影像数据库的 mega-analysis,纳入28个全球站点、年龄10-66岁的参与者。
- 比较惊恐障碍患者(N=1146)与健康对照(N=3778)的皮层和皮层下结构差异。
主要发现
- 惊恐障碍患者额-颞-顶叶区域皮层厚度更低、表面积更小(Cohen's ds: -0.08-0.13)。
- 惊恐障碍患者丘脑和尾状核体积更小(Cohen's ds: -0.07-0.12)。
- 诊断与年龄平方交互效应(Cohen's ds: 0.07-0.12)显示成年期(25-55岁)患者特定区域皮层厚度低于对照,青年(<25岁)和晚年(>55岁)相对无差异。
- 早发惊恐障碍(≤21岁)与侧脑室更大相关(Cohen's ds: 0.31-0.38),未发现用药、共病或严重程度效应。
临床怎么用
- 结构影像差异效应量较小,尚不足以作为惊恐障碍的个体化诊断或分型生物标志物。
- 早发患者侧脑室增大提示临床可关注早发惊恐障碍的神经发育因素。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性相关内容。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Neuroanatomical findings on panic disorder (PD) are typically difficult to replicate, with inconsistent effects. These concerns prompted a paradigm shift towards large-scale collaborations, focused on harmonized data extraction and processing for robust examination of PD brain correlates. Hence, leveraging the largest-ever multi-site neuroimaging database on PD (Age: 10-66 years; global sites: 28), compiled by the ENIGMA-Anxiety Working Group, we report on cortical and subcortical differences in individuals with PD (N = 1146) versus healthy controls (HC: N = 3778). The analyses revealed lower thickness and smaller cortical surface area within fronto-temporo-parietal regions in PD (Cohen's ds: -0.08-0.13), along with lower thalamic and caudate volumes (Cohen's ds: -0.07-0.12). Diagnosis-by-age2 interactions (Cohen's ds: 0.07-0.12) revealed lower thickness in individuals with PD compared to HC in certain regions during adulthood (25-55 years), with relative absence of such differences during youth (<25 years) or late adulthood (>55 years). Finally, patient subgroup analyses showed that early disease onset (≤21 years) in PD was associated with larger lateral ventricles (Cohen's ds: 0.31-0.38), whilst no medication, comorbidity, or severity effects were found. These findings lend support to neurocircuitry models of PD, which postulate differences within fronto-striato-limbic circuits and temporo-parietal regions. Moreover, findings highlight the potential importance of abnormal development and aging in neuroanatomical differences related to PD. Given its unprecedented scale, the current study is an important milestone towards identifying the structural brain correlates of PD.
引用
- Han LKM, Bruin WB, Bas-Hoogendam JM, et al. Structural brain differences associated with panic disorder: an ENIGMA-Anxiety Working Group mega-analysis of 4924 individuals worldwide. Mol Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 41530384. doi:10.1038/s41380-025-03376-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。