妄想作为具身情绪:英国首发精神病质性多方法研究
该研究对英国三个早期干预精神病团队的10名首发精神病患者进行质性多方法研究,通过临床精神病理学、现象学精神病理学和叙事探究三种视角分析妄想。研究发现妄想主题以被害、关系、夸大或宗教为主,妄想形成与早期反复负性人际情绪(尤其羞耻)及情绪调节方式相关,提出妄想是自我与世界情绪性转变的具身过程。
要点
- 妄想主题以被害(100%)、关系(90%)、夸大或宗教(90%)最常见,无单一主题孤立出现。
- 早期反复羞耻等负性情绪及经验回避或沉浸与妄想具身现象学相关。
- 妄想是自我与世界情绪性转变的具身认知语言过程。
核心结论
- 妄想的出现和演变反映了一个时间延展的、具身的、认知语言的过程,其特征是自我与世界的情绪性转变作为统一意识体验。
- 与相邻躯体体验相关的转喻思维和语言似乎可解释某些看似不可理解或极端的妄想性评价。
- 精神病预防和干预模型应考虑生活身体在情绪调节中的作用,以及周围物质和社会环境作为核心情感调节机制和潜在干预靶点。
研究设计与样本
- 质性驱动、多方法研究,招募英国三个早期干预精神病(EIP)团队中具有妄想体验的个体。
- 纳入标准:正在EIP服务治疗、过去或当前有临床显著妄想且精神科医生评定至少中度严重、年龄18-65岁、能知情同意并用英语访谈。
- 排除标准:仅与物质中毒或戒断相关的精神病性障碍。
- 采用多视角设计,从标准临床精神病理学(第三人称)、现象学精神病理学(自上而下获取第一人称数据)和叙事探究(自下而上获取第一人称数据)三个分析立场研究妄想。
- 妄想内容基于阳性症状量表(SAPS)定义分类;参与者完成标准化心理测量量表、叙事访谈(临时生活故事访谈)和现象学访谈(异常世界体验检查[EAWE])。
主要发现
- 三种最常见妄想主题:被害(10例[100%])、关系(9例[90%])、夸大或宗教(9例[90%]);无主题孤立出现。
- 第一叙事主题强调早期反复负性人际情绪(尤其羞耻)及后续经验回避或沉浸与吸收对理解晚年出现的妄想具身现象学的作用,包括反复羞耻、愤怒、恐惧和被控制感,以及妄想出现前应对情绪剧变。
- 第二叙事主题揭示世界与自我情绪转变的三种主要模式:聚光灯下从具身羞耻到全能无敌;成为更大事物一部分从无意义和缺失到具身爱、敬畏和希望;处于模拟中无身体生活、与他人隔绝。
关键数值与推荐
- 妄想主题分类基于阳性症状量表(SAPS)定义。
- 妄想严重度由主治精神科医生评定至少中度严重。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估可关注早期反复羞耻等负性人际情绪及经验回避或沉浸模式,将其作为理解妄想形成的线索。
- 干预模型可考虑生活身体在情绪调节中的作用,以及物质和社会环境作为情感调节机制和潜在干预靶点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Delusions in psychosis involve complex and dynamic experiential, affective, cognitive, behavioural, and interpersonal alterations. Their pattern of emergence during the early stages of illness remains poorly understood and the origin of their thematic content unclear. Phenomenological accounts have emphasised alterations of selfhood and reality experience in delusion formation but have not considered the role of life events and other contextual factors in the development of these disturbances. This study aimed to investigate the relationship between self-experience and the lived world in first-episode psychosis by situating the phenomenological analysis of delusions in the context of the person's life narrative. METHODS: In this qualitatively driven study, we recruited individuals with lived experience of delusions receiving care from three Early Intervention in Psychosis (EIP) teams in the UK. People with lived experience were involved in the development of the study design and protocol. Inclusion criteria were that the individual was being treated within an EIP service; past or current experience of clinically significant delusions, assessed by the attending psychiatrist to be at least of moderate severity; aged between 18 and 65 years; and willing and able to give informed consent and able to undertake interviews in English. Exclusion criteria included presence of a psychotic disorder solely related to substance intoxication or withdrawal. We used a novel multi-perspectival design to investigate delusions across three analytical standpoints: standard clinical psychopathology (third person), phenomenological psychopathology (a top-down approach to eliciting first-person data), and narrative inquiry (a bottom-up approach to eliciting first-person data). Delusion content was classified based on the definitions provided by the Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms. Participants completed standardised psychometric scales, a narrative interview (ad-hoc Life Story Interview), and a phenomenological (Examination of Anomalous World Experience [EAWE]) interview. Findings were integrated through meta-inference across analytical frameworks. FINDINGS: Between Jan 4, 2023, and June 14, 2023, 33 interview sessions were completed with ten adults with first-episode psychosis and lived experience of delusions (three men, six women, and one person who was non-binary; median age 24·5 years [IQR 14·8]; eight White, two White and Black Caribbean). The three most common delusion themes were: persecutory (ten [100%]), reference (nine [90%]), and grandiose or religious (nine [90%]). No theme occurred in isolation. The phenomenological component of the analysis revealed a global, qualitative shift in the subjective experience of the lived world, with total EAWE scores ranging from 13 to 48 (mean 26·5 [SD 10·85]). The first narrative theme highlighted the role of early and repeated negative interpersonal emotions (especially shame) and subsequent experiential avoidance or immersion and absorption to understand the embodied phenomenology of delusions emerging in later life: (1) recurrent shame, anger, fear, and feelings of being controlled; and (2) "it really turned my whole life upside down": coping with emotional upheavals before the onset of delusions. The second narrative theme revealed three main patterns of emotional transformation of the world and the self: (1) being under the spotlight: from embodied shame to almighty invincibility; (2) being part of something bigger: from meaninglessness and absence to embodied love, awe, and hope; and (3) being in a simulation: life without a body, cut off from others. INTERPRETATION: The emergence and evolution of delusions reflected a temporally extended, embodied, and cognitive-linguistic process characterised by an emotional transformation of the self and the world as a unified conscious experience. Metonymic thinking and language linked to contiguous bodily experiences appeared to explain some of the apparently incomprehensible or extreme delusional appraisals of self and world, such as being a bad person or being connected to God. Prevention and intervention models for psychosis should consider the role of the lived body for the regulation of emotions, and the effect of the surrounding material and social environments as central affective-regulatory mechanisms, and potential targets for intervention and support. FUNDING: Priestley Scholarship and the Wellcome Trust.
引用
- Ritunnano R, Littlemore J, Nelson B, et al. Delusion as embodied emotion: a qualitatively driven, multimethod study of first-episode psychosis in the UK. Lancet Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 41539315. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(25)00341-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。