当代精神病学中被遗忘的心境状态:烦躁不安亟需诊断识别
本文综述指出,烦躁不安(dysphoria)以易激惹性紧张、普遍不满和厌恶情绪为特征,在DSM-5-TR和ICD-11中被边缘化为症状描述符而非独立诊断实体。文章综合神经精神病学、现象学和诊断研究证据,论证应在维度框架内将烦躁不安操作化为跨诊断的情感维度,以减少诊断不精确和医源性伤害。
要点
- 烦躁不安是跨诊断的情感维度,当前主要诊断系统未将其作为独立实体。
- 其表现异质:癫痫为发作性敌意,精神分裂症为情感疏离混合易激惹,人格病理为核心失调。
- 排除其作为主要构念可导致误诊为抑郁或行为障碍,以及抗抑郁药所致激越等医源性伤害。
核心结论
- 应在维度框架内操作化烦躁不安,以阐明其独特病理生理、减少医源性伤害并推进靶向干预。
- 正式承认烦躁不安为独立构念是伦理和临床的迫切要求,否则将延续诊断不精确、治疗失误和可预防的痛苦。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,综合神经精神病学、现象学和诊断研究证据。
- 批判性审视历史类型学(如方向性、时间性和结构复杂性)与当代维度模型(如RDoC负性效价系统)。
主要发现
- 烦躁不安在癫痫中表现为发作性敌意(如发作间期烦躁障碍)。
- 在精神分裂症中表现为情感疏离混合易激惹。
- 在人格病理中表现为核心失调(如边缘型空虚、反社会敌意)。
- 其被排除为主要构念导致诊断不准确(误归为抑郁或行为障碍)和医源性伤害(如抗抑郁药所致激越)。
- 历史类型学对风险评估和治疗规划仍具临床效用。
临床怎么用
- 临床应识别烦躁不安的异质表现,避免误归为抑郁或行为障碍。
- 关注抗抑郁药可能诱发激越等医源性风险。
- 利用历史类型学辅助风险评估和治疗规划。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Dysphoria - characterised by irritable tension, pervasive discontent and aversive emotionality - is a clinically significant yet nosologically ambiguous phenomenon. It remains marginalised in major diagnostic systems (DSM-5-TR, ICD-11), relegated to a symptomatic descriptor rather than a validated entity, perpetuating diagnostic imprecision and therapeutic risks. AIMS: This review argues for the formal recognition of dysphoria as a distinct transdiagnostic affective dimension. It synthesises evidence to demonstrate its neurobehavioural correlates, protean manifestations across disorders and the clinical imperative for its operationalisation within dimensional frameworks. METHOD: We conducted a synthesis of evidence across neuropsychiatry, phenomenology and diagnostic research. Historical typologies (e.g. directionality (extrapunitive versus intrapunitive), temporality (paroxysmal versus chronic) and structural complexity) and contemporary dimensional models (e.g. RDoC's Negative Valence Systems) were critically examined. RESULTS: Dysphoria manifests heterogeneously across conditions: as paroxysmal hostility in epilepsy (e.g. interictal dysphoric disorder), affective estrangement in schizophrenia (irritability blended with detachment) and core dysregulation in personality pathology (e.g. borderline emptiness, antisocial hostility). Its exclusion as a primary construct leads to diagnostic inaccuracy (misattribution to depression or behavioural disorders) and iatrogenic harm (e.g. antidepressant-induced agitation). Historical typologies retain clinical utility for risk assessment and treatment planning. CONCLUSIONS: Operationalising dysphoria within dimensional frameworks is essential to elucidate its unique pathophysiology, mitigate iatrogenic harm and advance targeted interventions. Formal recognition of dysphoria as a distinct construct is an ethical and clinical imperative - failure to do so perpetuates diagnostic imprecision, therapeutic missteps and preventable suffering.
引用
- Skryabin V, Kolobov K, Mikhailov M, et al. Dysphoria in contemporary psychiatry: forgotten affective state in need of diagnostic recognition. Br J Psychiatry. 2026. PMID: 41498284. doi:10.1192/bjp.2025.10518
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。