NHS谈话治疗中低强度与高强度认知行为疗法混合模式初步评估
该研究在NHS谈话治疗项目中探索由双培训治疗师根据患者需求灵活切换低强度与高强度认知行为疗法的混合治疗模式。结果显示混合治疗平均减少4次会谈、节省三分之一治疗师时间、提前121天完成治疗,可靠康复率54.1%较对照组44.7%高9%,但差异未达统计学显著。
要点
- 双培训治疗师实施的混合治疗较阶梯式治疗平均少4次会谈且节省三分之一治疗师时间
- 混合治疗组可靠康复率54.1%,较阶梯式治疗组44.7%高9%,临床意义但非统计学显著
- 混合治疗可靠恶化率非显著更高,患者反馈积极,治疗师和督导指出优势与实践挑战
核心结论
- 混合治疗模式在双培训临床医生中显示出高效且有效的潜力,可提供更灵活无缝的照护,但需更大规模研究和实施挑战考量。
主要发现
- 与接受低强度后高强度治疗的匹配对照组相比,混合治疗平均少4次会谈,节省三分之一治疗师时间,提前121天完成治疗。
- 混合治疗可靠康复率为54.1%,较阶梯式治疗组44.7%高9%,临床显著但未达统计学显著。
- 混合治疗可靠恶化率非显著更高,患者反馈积极。
临床怎么用
- 双培训治疗师可根据患者需求灵活在低强度与高强度认知行为疗法间切换,避免阶梯式升级中的治疗师更换和额外等待。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A stepped care approach to treating anxiety and depression is common in mental health services. Low-intensity interventions, typically based on cognitive behavioural principles, are offered first, followed by high-intensity therapy if required. In the English National Health Service Talking Therapies (NHS TT) programme, different types of therapists deliver low- and high-intensity interventions. 'Stepping up' therefore involves changing therapist, and often an additional wait, which could both disrupt treatment flow.In NHS TT, many low-intensity therapists subsequently train at high intensity. Once dual-trained, they typically deliver only high-intensity treatment. With both skillsets, they could theoretically deliver a full stepped care pathway, avoiding potential disruption linked to stepping up. AIMS: To explore a blended treatment approach, where dual-trained therapists move between low- and high-intensity flexibly based on patient need. METHOD: Ten dual-trained therapists across 4 services treated 43 patients. Patients with clinical complexities more likely to eventually require high-intensity support were selected. Propensity score matching was used to identify matched control groups from a pool of patients who received stepped care. Treatment characteristics and clinical outcomes were compared. Feedback was obtained from patients, therapists and supervisors. RESULTS: Compared with matched controls, who received low- then high-intensity treatment, blended treatment required four fewer sessions on average, saving a third of therapist time and was completed 121 days sooner. The reliable recovery rate (54.1%) was 9% higher than the stepped care group (44.7%), which is clinically, although not statistically, significant. Blended treatment showed a non-significantly higher reliable deterioration rate. Patient feedback was positive. Therapists and supervisors highlighted advantages alongside practical challenges. CONCLUSIONS: The blended approach showed promise as an efficient and effective method to deliver therapy when clinicians are dual-trained. Larger-scale studies, and consideration of implementation challenges, are needed. However, results suggest that this approach could potentially offer more flexible and seamless care delivery.
引用
- Thew GR, O'Reilly L, Andrews A, et al. Blending low- and high-intensity cognitive-behavioural therapy in NHS Talking Therapies for anxiety and depression: preliminary evaluation. Br J Psychiatry. 2025. PMID: 40968478. doi:10.1192/bjp.2025.10374
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。