重新评估成瘾的脑疾病模型
该文重新审视成瘾的脑疾病模型,指出缺乏一致、清晰的脑疾病定义阻碍了成瘾研究讨论与知识推进。作者借用精神病学哲学区分狭义与广义脑疾病观,分析各自的理论假设、实证证据与治疗启示,并提出超越两种观点的路径。
要点
- 成瘾脑疾病模型缺乏一致、清晰的脑疾病定义,阻碍了有效讨论与知识进步。
- 狭义脑疾病观要求精神状况类似典型脑疾病,由已知或未知的结构与功能损伤所致。
- 广义脑疾病观认为所有精神障碍自动属于脑疾病,因所有心理活动均位于大脑。
核心结论
- 缺乏一致、清晰且连贯的脑疾病定义,加之频繁使用含义分歧或漂移的概念,阻碍了关于成瘾是否应被概念化为脑疾病的有效辩论与知识进步。
- 狭义与广义脑疾病观在成瘾研究中并存并产生影响,但常以隐晦且不一致的方式呈现。
- 作者提出超越狭义与广义脑疾病观的路径。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为个人观点(Personal View)文章,非系统综述或原创研究。
主要发现
- 该模型 purportedly 兼具病因学理论与减少污名工具的双重目的。
- 实证支持薄弱以及对模型淡化SUD根本心理社会原因的担忧,导致关于成瘾是否应被概念化为脑疾病的尖锐分歧。
- 狭义脑疾病观认为,只有当一个精神状况表现得类似典型脑疾病(由已知或未知的结构与功能损伤所致)时,才符合脑疾病的条件。
- 广义脑疾病观认为,应自动赋予精神障碍以脑疾病地位,因为所有心理活动都位于大脑。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The brain disease model of addiction has dominated public and scientific discourse on addiction (termed substance use disorder [SUD] in the DSM-5) over the past 3 decades. The model framed addiction as a chronic and relapsing brain disease caused by structural and functional brain alterations. The purpose of this model was purportedly dual, as both an aetiological theory and a tool to reduce stigma. Weak empirical support and concerns about the model downplaying fundamental psychosocial causes of SUDs have led to stark disagreement as to whether addiction should be conceptualised as a brain disease. In this Personal View, we argue that the absence of an agreed, clear, and consistent definition of a brain disease-coupled with frequent recourse to concepts with divergent or shifting meaning-have obstructed productive debate and a coherent advance in knowledge and understanding of addiction. Borrowing from the philosophy of psychiatry, we show that both narrow and broad views of brain disease coexist and inform addiction research, though often implicitly and inconsistently. The narrow view of brain disease posits that a mental condition qualifies as a brain disease only if it manifests similarly to a paradigmatic brain disease, resulting from either known or unknown structural and functional damage. The broad view of brain disease suggests that brain disease status should be granted automatically to mental disorders, as all mental activity resides in the brain. We examine theoretical assumptions, empirical evidence, and treatment implications for each view and propose ways of moving beyond them.
引用
- Blithikioti C, Fried EI, Albanese E, et al. Reevaluating the brain disease model of addiction. Lancet Psychiatry. 2025. PMID: 40154515. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(25)00060-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。