文献速递心境障碍焦虑、强迫与应激相关障碍精神分裂症与精神病性障碍

期望效应、盲法完整性失效与安慰剂反应在精神障碍治疗试验中的影响:一篇叙述性综述

Expectancy Effects, Failure of Blinding Integrity, and Placebo Response in Trials of Treatments for Psychiatric Disorders: A Narrative Review.
PubMed 文献 · JAMA Psychiatry · 2025-01-01

这篇叙述性综述探讨了精神科随机临床试验中期望效应、盲法完整性受损与活性治疗/安慰剂效应之间的关系。文章指出期望是安慰剂反应的关键特异性成分,感知到的疗效和不良反应可能破坏盲法并引入偏倚,致幻剂和焦虑障碍领域的荟萃分析数据表明盲法破坏可影响效应量。作者推荐在监测盲法完整性的同时收集治疗期望数据,并开发受期望效应影响较小的客观读数。

要点

  • 期望效应是精神科随机临床试验的重要混杂因素,可能影响结果解读。
  • 感知到的疗效和不良反应可能破坏盲法完整性,引入结局评估偏倚。
  • 致幻剂和焦虑障碍领域的荟萃分析数据表明盲法破坏可影响效应量。

核心结论

  • 期望效应是精神科随机临床试验中的显著混杂因素。
  • 作者推荐在监测盲法完整性的同时收集治疗期望数据,以更准确地解读研究结果。
  • 开发受期望效应混杂影响较小的客观读数,是减轻精神科随机临床试验中此类混杂影响的另一有前景的途径。

研究设计与样本

  • 叙述性综述,据作者所知是首篇探讨精神科随机临床试验中期望效应、盲法完整性受损与活性治疗/安慰剂效应之间关系的综述。

主要发现

  • 安慰剂反应包含特异性和非特异性成分,期望是其中关键的特异性成分。
  • 实验和临床研究的证据提示期望可影响随机临床试验中的治疗反应。
  • 盲法完整性可能因感知到的治疗疗效和不良反应而受损,从而在结局评估中引入偏倚。
  • 治疗期望可导致随机临床试验中盲法被破坏,来自致幻剂和焦虑障碍领域研究的荟萃分析数据表明这可影响效应量。
  • 新的统计方法虽仍需进一步验证,但为解决该问题提供了策略;实验医学模型旨在开发受期望效应影响较小的客观改善标志物(读数)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者推荐在监测盲法完整性的同时收集治疗期望数据,以更准确地解读研究结果。
  • 作者提出开发受期望效应混杂影响较小的客观读数,是减轻精神科随机临床试验中此类混杂影响的有前景途径。

局限性

  • 新的统计方法仍需进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

IMPORTANCE: Expectancy effects are significant confounding factors in psychiatric randomized clinical trials (RCTs), potentially affecting the interpretation of study results. This narrative review is the first, to our knowledge, to explore the relationship between expectancy effects, compromised blinding integrity, and the effects of active treatment/placebo in psychiatric RCTs. Additionally, we present statistical and experimental approaches that may help mitigate the confounding impact of expectancy effects. The review concludes with recommendations to enhance the reliability of RCTs in psychiatry. OBSERVATIONS: The placebo response comprises both specific and nonspecific elements, with expectation being a key specific component. Evidence from experimental and clinical studies suggests that expectancy can influence treatment responses in RCTs. Blinding integrity may be compromised by perceived treatment efficacy and adverse effects, introducing bias into outcome assessments. Treatment expectations can lead to unblinding during RCTs, and meta-analytic data from studies in the fields of psychedelics and anxiety disorders indicate that this can influence effect sizes. Therefore, controlling for expectancy effects is essential when interpreting RCT results. Novel statistical methods, though still in need of further validation, offer strategies to address this issue. Another approach may involve experimental medicine models, which aim to develop objective improvement markers (readouts) less affected by expectancy effects. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Expectancy effects represent a significant confound in psychiatric RCTs. We recommend collecting data on treatment expectations alongside monitoring blinding integrity to more accurately interpret study results. Additionally, developing objective readouts that are less confounded by expectancy effects offers another promising avenue for mitigating these confounding influences in psychiatric RCTs.

来源:JAMA Psychiatry,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Huneke NTM, Fusetto Veronesi G, Garner M, et al. Expectancy Effects, Failure of Blinding Integrity, and Placebo Response in Trials of Treatments for Psychiatric Disorders: A Narrative Review. JAMA Psychiatry. 2025. PMID: 40072447. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2025.0085

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。