英国南亚裔女性产后抑郁团体心理干预的成本效益:ROSHNI-2试验的经济学评价
ROSHNI-2试验是一项多中心、双臂、评估者盲法随机对照试验,比较文化适配的认知行为疗法(积极健康计划,PHP)联合常规治疗与单纯常规治疗对英国南亚裔产后抑郁女性的成本效益。从英国国家卫生服务和个人社会服务视角进行12个月经济学评价,PHP显著增加成本(£712,95%CI 311至1113)和QALYs(0.036,95%CI 0.006至0.067),增量成本效果比为£19601(7622至83772);以NICE每QALY £30000的支付意愿阈值,PHP具有成本效益的可能性为77%。
要点
- PHP联合常规治疗较单纯常规治疗显著增加成本£712(95%CI 311至1113)和QALYs 0.036(95%CI 0.006至0.067)。
- 增量成本效果比为£19601(95%CI 7622至83772),低于NICE每QALY £20000-30000阈值的下限。
- 基于NICE每QALY £30000阈值,PHP具有成本效益的可能性为77%。
核心结论
- 作者认为,PHP这种文化适配的团体认知行为疗法干预可能对英国南亚裔女性产后抑郁具有成本效益。
- 作者指出,在线PHP交付在该人群中显示出有前景的临床和成本效益结果,但需要大规模研究。
研究设计与样本
- ROSHNI-2试验为多中心、双臂、评估者盲法随机对照试验,从英国国家卫生服务和个人社会服务视角进行12个月经济学评价。
- 2017年2月8日至2020年3月29日共纳入732名符合DSM-5抑郁标准的英国南亚裔女性,年龄≥16岁且孩子≤12个月,随机分配至PHP组(368例)或常规治疗组(364例)。
- PHP干预包括12次团体课程,由两名受训双语促进者实施,前2个月每周一次、之后每两周一次,每次60-90分钟。
- 基线、4个月(干预结束)和随机分配后12个月完成抑郁症状、生活质量和资源使用问卷;以QALYs进行成本效用分析,以4个月时汉密尔顿抑郁评定量表评估的抑郁康复(主要临床结局)进行成本效果分析。
- COVID-19大流行后,剩余参与者的干预调整为在线交付,并进行了在线与面对面交付的成本效益分层分析。
主要发现
- 基础病例意向性治疗分析显示,PHP显著增加成本£712(95%CI 311至1113)和QALYs 0.036(95%CI 0.006至0.067),增量成本效果比为£19601(95%CI 7622至83772)。
- 基于英国NICE每QALY £30000的最大支付意愿阈值,从健康和社会照护视角,PHP具有成本效益的可能性为77%。
- 4个月随访时抑郁康复的每例成本为£5509(95%CI 2916至17860)。
- 在大流行期间参加在线课程的34名参与者的分层分析中,增量QALY效应为0.125(95%CI 0.048至0.203),每获得一个额外QALY的成本为£202(95%CI -3906至10918)。
关键数值与推荐
- NICE每QALY最大支付意愿阈值为£30000,阈值为每QALY £20000-30000。
- PHP组较常规治疗组成本增加£712(95%CI 311至1113),QALYs增加0.036(95%CI 0.006至0.067)。
- 增量成本效果比为£19601(95%CI 7622至83772)。
- 4个月抑郁康复每例成本为£5509(95%CI 2916至17860)。
- 在线交付分层分析(34例)增量QALY效应为0.125(95%CI 0.048至0.203),每额外QALY成本£202(95%CI -3906至10918)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,PHP可能是一种对英国南亚裔女性产后抑郁具有成本效益的干预。
- 作者指出,在线PHP交付显示出有前景的临床和成本效益结果,但需要大规模研究。
局限性
- 作者指出,在线PHP交付需要大规模研究。
- 作者指出,PHP的平均成本低于NICE每QALY £20000-30000阈值的下限,但未计入对孩子的获益或早期康复带来的减少生产力损失等潜在收益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minority ethnic groups often face ethnocultural barriers in accessing mental health treatments. The ROSHNI-2 trial compared culturally adapted cognitive behavioural therapy (Positive Health Programme [PHP]) with treatment as usual for postnatal depression in British south Asian women. We aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness of the PHP intervention. METHODS: The ROSHNI-2 trial was a multicentre, two-arm, assessor-blinded, randomised controlled trial; we conducted an economic evaluation over a 12-month period to assess the cost-effectiveness of PHP plus treatment as usual versus treatment as usual alone from the perspective of the English National Health Service and personal social services. In the trial, British south Asian women aged 16 years or older with a child aged up to 12 months, and meeting DSM-5 criteria for depression, were recruited from northwest England, Yorkshire, the East Midlands, and London. The PHP intervention involved 12 group sessions delivered by two trained bilingual facilitators, held once per week for 2 months and once per fortnight thereafter, each lasting 60-90 min. Questionnaires on depression symptoms, quality of life, and resource use were completed at baseline, 4 months (end of intervention), and 12 months after random assignment. Quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) were used for the cost-utility analysis, and recovery from depression at 4 months (the primary clinical outcome), assessed using the Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression, informed the cost-effectiveness analysis. After the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the intervention was adapted for online delivery for the remaining participants. A stratified analysis compared the cost-effectiveness of online versus in-person delivery. The trial involved researchers with lived experience, and all methods, including health economic measures, were developed in consultation with service users, community members, and faith leaders. This is a preplanned analysis of the ROSHNI-2 trial, registered with ISRCTN (ISRCTN10697380). FINDINGS: From Feb 8, 2017, to March 29, 2020, 732 eligible women were enrolled: 368 participants were randomly assigned to the PHP arm and 364 to the treatment as usual arm. The base-case intention-to-treat analysis showed that PHP significantly increased costs (£712, 95% CI 311 to 1113) and QALYs (0·036, 95% CI 0·006 to 0·067), with an incremental cost-effectiveness ratio of £19 601 (7622 to 83 772). Based on the UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) maximum willingness-to-pay threshold of £30 000 per QALY, the likelihood of PHP being cost-effective was 77% from a health and social care perspective. Cost per remission from depression at the 4-month follow-up was £5509 (2916 to 17 860). In a stratified analysis of 34 participants attending online sessions during the pandemic, incremental QALY effects were 0·125 (0·048 to 0·203), resulting in costs of £202 (-3906 to 10 918) per additional QALY gained. INTERPRETATION: The average cost of PHP for postpartum women was below the lower end of the NICE threshold of £20 000-30 000 per QALY, excluding benefits to the child or potential gains such as reduced lost productivity from early remission. PHP, a culturally adapted group cognitive behavioural therapy-based intervention, might be a cost-effective intervention for postnatal depression in British south Asian women. Online PHP delivery showed promising clinical and cost-effective results for this group but requires a large-scale study. FUNDING: UK National Institute for Health and Care Research.
引用
- Ullah A, Lunat F, Brugha T, et al. Cost-effectiveness of a group psychological intervention for postnatal depression in British south Asian women: an economic evaluation from the ROSHNI-2 trial. Lancet Psychiatry. 2025. PMID: 40112855. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(25)00039-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。