英格兰中学年龄段少数族裔青少年应激相关表现急诊入院情况
该回顾性队列研究纳入2014年4月至2020年3月期间11至15岁有一次及以上急诊入院史的青少年,分析不同种族-族裔群体应激相关表现(SRP)的发生率、分布、住院时长和类型。结果显示SRP入院模式在各群体间存在系统性差异,提示分诊、评估和治疗过程存在不公平,作者提出需实施种族平等框架以应对医疗路径中的结构性种族主义。
要点
- 白人英国裔(每1000名出生8-38例)与混血白-黑裔(每1000名出生9-42例)SRP发生率最高,黑人非洲裔、印度裔和白人其他裔最低。
- 再入院比例最高为巴基斯坦裔(47.7%)、白人英国裔(41.4%)和混血白-黑裔(41.3%),最低为黑人其他裔(36.4%)和白人其他裔(35.8%)。
- 住院时长≥3天的比例在黑人其他裔(16.6%)、孟加拉裔(16.3%)、亚洲其他裔(15.9%)和黑人加勒比裔(15.8%)高于白人英国裔(11.9%)和印度裔(11.8%)。
核心结论
- SRP入院模式在不同种族-族裔群体间存在系统性差异,提示分诊、评估和治疗过程存在不公平。
- 作者认为这些发现凸显了实施种族平等框架以应对医疗路径中结构性种族主义的必要性。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2014年4月至2020年3月期间英格兰11至15岁、有一次及以上急诊入院史的青少年,按种族-族裔分组分析SRP。
- SRP定义为因潜在心身症状、自伤以及内化性、外化性和思维障碍而急诊入院。
主要发现
- 白人英国裔(每1000名出生8-38例)和混血白-黑裔(每1000名出生9-42例)SRP发生率最高;黑人非洲裔(5-14例/1000)、印度裔(6-19例/1000)和白人其他裔(4-19例/1000)最低。
- 再入院比例最高为巴基斯坦裔(47.7%)、白人英国裔(41.4%)和混血白-黑裔(41.3%);最低为黑人其他裔(36.4%)和白人其他裔(35.8%)。
- 住院时长≥3天的比例在黑人其他裔(16.6%)、孟加拉裔(16.3%)、亚洲其他裔(15.9%)和黑人加勒比裔(15.8%)高于白人英国裔(11.9%)和印度裔(11.8%)。
- SRP的类型在不同种族-族裔群体间存在差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,这些发现凸显了实施种族平等框架以应对医疗路径中结构性种族主义的必要性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minoritised young people face a double burden of discrimination through increased risk of stress and differential treatment access. However, acute care pathways for minoritised young people with urgent mental health needs are poorly understood. AIMS: To explore variation in stress-related presentations (SRPs) to acute hospitals across racial-ethnic groups in England. METHOD: We examined rates, distribution, duration and types of SRPs across racial-ethnic groups in a retrospective cohort of 11- to 15-year-olds with one or more emergency hospital admissions between April 2014 and March 2020. SRPs were defined as emergency admissions for potentially psychosomatic symptoms, self-harm and internalising, externalising and thought disorders. RESULTS: White British (8-38 per 1000 births) and Mixed White-Black (9-42 per 1000 births) young people had highest rates of SRPs, whereas Black African (5-14 per 1000 births), Indian (6-19 per 1000 births) and White other (4-19 per 1000 births) young people had the lowest rates of SRPs. The proportion of readmissions were highest for Pakistani (47.7%), White British (41.4%) and Mixed White-Black (41.3%) groups. Black Other (36.4%) and White Other (35.8%) groups had the lowest proportions of readmissions. The proportion of admission durations ≥3 days was higher for Black Other (16.6%), Bangladeshi (16.3%), Asian Other (15.9%) and Black Caribbean (15.8%) groups than their White British (11.9%) and Indian (11.8%) peers. The type of SRPs varied across racial-ethnic groups. CONCLUSIONS: Patterns of SRP admissions systematically differed across racial-ethnic groups, indicative of inequitable triage, assessment and treatment processes. These findings highlight the need for implementation of race equality frameworks to address structural racism in healthcare pathways.
引用
- Ní Chobhthaigh S, Jay MA, Blackburn R, et al. Emergency hospital admissions for stress-related presentations among secondary school-aged minoritised young people in England. Br J Psychiatry. 2024. PMID: 39523214. doi:10.1192/bjp.2024.123
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。