青少年内化症状的经济不平等:来自八个国家的纵向证据
这项纵向观察性队列研究分析了八个国家2000至2019年间18910名青少年的数据,发现家庭收入与青少年内化症状关联较小或为零,家庭消费支出关联较强,在秘鲁、南非和越南家庭消费支出翻倍时内化症状分别降低0.075、0.034和0.141个标准差,主观财富在五国中的四国与内化症状相关。
要点
- 家庭收入与青少年内化症状的关联较小或为零,异质性I²=71.04%,调整基线症状后降至39.71%。
- 家庭消费支出翻倍时,秘鲁内化症状降低0.075 SD(95%CI -0.136至-0.013),南非降低0.034 SD(-0.061至-0.006),越南降低0.141 SD(-0.202至-0.081)。
- 青少年主观财富在五国中的四国与内化症状相关,解释的症状变异大于客观经济指标。
核心结论
- 研究提示青少年心理健康的经济不平等在许多但并非所有国家普遍存在,且因所考虑的经济指标而异。
- 不平等程度的差异提示国家内部更广泛的背景在这些不平等的形成中起重要作用。
研究设计与样本
- 纵向观察性队列研究,分析八个国家(澳大利亚、埃塞俄比亚、印度、墨西哥、秘鲁、南非、英国和越南)涵盖五个全球区域的研究数据,数据收集于2000至2019年间。
- 所有研究均在青少年期两个时间点使用经验证的量表自报内化症状,并测量家庭收入、家庭消费支出或主观财富。
- 家庭收入(四国测量)、消费支出(六国测量)和青少年对家庭财富的主观评估(五国测量)于青春期中期(14-17岁)测量,主要结局内化症状于青春期后期17至19岁测量。
- 分析采用调整后的线性回归模型,效应估计量纳入随机效应Meta分析以帮助理解跨国差异。
- 八项研究汇总样本共18910名青少年,其中女性9568名(50.6%),男性9342名(49.4%)。
主要发现
- 家庭收入与青少年内化症状的关联较小或为零,异质性I²=71.04%,调整基线症状后降至39.71%。
- 家庭消费支出与内化症状关联较强:家庭消费支出翻倍时,秘鲁内化症状降低0.075 SD(95%CI -0.136至-0.013),南非降低0.034 SD(95%CI -0.061至-0.006),越南降低0.141 SD(95%CI -0.202至-0.081)。
- 家庭消费支出的异质性I²=74.24%,调整基线症状后为74.83%,保持相似。
- 青少年主观财富在五国中的四国与内化症状相关,异质性I²=57.09%,调整基线症状后为53.25%,保持相似。
- 研究发现青少年内化症状经济不平等存在跨国差异,最突出的是家庭消费支出方面的不平等,主观财富解释的症状变异大于客观指标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Research, mainly conducted in Europe and North America, has shown an inequitable burden of internalising mental health problems among adolescents from poorer households. We investigated whether these mental health inequalities differ across a diverse range of countries and multiple measures of economic circumstances. METHODS: In this longitudinal observational cohort study, we analysed data from studies conducted in eight countries (Australia, Ethiopia, India, Mexico, Peru, South Africa, the UK, and Viet Nam) across five global regions. All studies had self-reported measures of internalising symptoms using a validated scale at two timepoints in adolescence; a measure of household income, household consumption expenditure, or subjective wealth; and data collected between 2000 and 2019. Household income (measured in four countries), consumption expenditure (six countries), and adolescents' subjective assessment of household wealth (five countries) were measured in mid-adolescence (14-17 years). The primary outcome (internalising symptoms, characterised by negative mood, affect, and anxiety) was measured later in adolescence between age 17 and 19 years. Analyses were linear regression models with adjustment. Effect estimates were added to random-effects meta-analyses to aid understanding of cross-country differences. FINDINGS: The overall pooled sample of eight studies featured 18 910 adolescents (9568 [50·6%] female and 9342 [49·4%] male). Household income had a small or null association with adolescents' internalising symptoms. Heterogeneity (I2 statistic) was 71·04%, falling to 39·71% after adjusting for baseline symptoms. Household consumption expenditure had a stronger association with internalising symptoms (decreases of 0·075 SD in Peru [95% CI -0·136 to -0·013], 0·034 SD in South Africa [-0·061 to -0·006], and 0·141 SD in Viet Nam [-0·202 to -0·081] as household consumption expenditure doubled). The I2 statistic was 74·24%, remaining similar at 74·83% after adjusting for baseline symptoms. Adolescents' subjective wealth was associated with internalising symptoms in four of the five countries where it was measured. The I2 statistic was 57·09% and remained similar after adjusting for baseline symptoms (53·25%). We found evidence for cross-country differences in economic inequalities in adolescents' internalising symptoms, most prominently for inequalities according to household consumption expenditure. Subjective wealth explained greater variance in symptoms compared with the objective measures. INTERPRETATION: Our study suggests that economic inequalities in adolescents' mental health are prevalent in many but not all countries and vary by the economic measure considered. Variation in the magnitude of inequalities suggests that the wider context within countries plays an important role in the development of these inequalities. FUNDING: Wellcome Trust.
引用
- Steare T, Evans-Lacko S, Araya M, et al. Economic inequalities in adolescents' internalising symptoms: longitudinal evidence from eight countries. Lancet Psychiatry. 2024. PMID: 39419562. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(24)00255-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。