空气污染与气候变化对心理健康结局的影响:全球证据伞状综述
该伞状综述系统检索PubMed/Medline、Scopus和PsycINFO(截至2023年6月26日),纳入32篇系统综述与meta分析(含284项原始研究、237个关联),评估空气污染或气候变化暴露与心理健康结局的关联。12个关联(5.0%)达到令人信服(I级)或高度提示(II级)证据,多数关联效应量较小但覆盖全球人群,可能具有实质性影响。
要点
- 长期暴露于溶剂与痴呆或认知障碍发病率升高存在令人信服(I级)证据(OR=1.139)。
- 妊娠中期暴露于PM10与产后抑郁发生存在高度提示(II级)证据(每1 μg/m3增加OR=1.023)。
- 短期温度升高与自杀或精神障碍相关死亡率、自杀行为及住院/急诊访问存在高度提示(II级)证据。
核心结论
- 空气污染和气候变化对心理健康存在全球性负面影响,12个关联达到令人信服或高度提示证据级别。
- 多数关联效应量较小,但覆盖全球人群,可能产生实质性影响。
研究设计与样本
- 伞状综述,系统检索PubMed/Medline、Scopus和PsycINFO数据库至2023年6月26日。
- 纳入32篇系统综述与meta分析,涵盖284项原始研究和237个暴露-结局关联。
- 使用R metaumbrella包按令人信服、高度提示、提示或弱分级标准评估证据可信度,并辅以敏感性分析。
主要发现
- 237个关联中195个(82.3%)涉及空气污染,42个(17.7%)涉及气候变化危害(其中35个聚焦温度)。
- 心理健康结局中185个(78.1%)涉及精神障碍,29个(12.4%)涉及自杀行为,9个(3.7%)涉及心理健康服务可及性,8个(3.3%)涉及精神障碍相关症状,6个(2.5%)涉及多类别。
- 12个关联(5.0%)达到令人信服(I级)或高度提示(II级)证据。
- 空气污染方面:长期暴露于溶剂与痴呆或认知障碍发病率升高存在令人信服证据(OR=1.139);长期暴露于一氧化碳高 vs 低水平与痴呆发病率升高存在高度提示证据(OR=1.587);氮氧化物每1 μg/m3增加与血管性痴呆发病率存在高度提示证据(HR=1.004)。
- 气候变化方面:短期温度每1°C增加与自杀或精神障碍相关死亡率(RR=1.024)、自杀行为(RR=1.012)、自杀行为或精神障碍所致住院/急诊访问(RR=1.011)及仅精神障碍所致住院/急诊访问(RR=1.009)存在高度提示证据;短期表观温度每1°C增加与自杀行为存在高度提示证据(RR=1.01);气旋暴露时间邻近性与创伤后应激障碍症状严重程度存在高度提示证据(r=0.275)。
关键数值与推荐
- 证据分级标准:令人信服(I级)、高度提示(II级)、提示或弱,依据R metaumbrella包标准并辅以敏感性分析。
- 长期暴露于溶剂与痴呆或认知障碍:OR=1.139(令人信服,I级)。
- 长期暴露于一氧化碳高 vs 低水平与痴呆:OR=1.587(高度提示,II级)。
- 氮氧化物每1 μg/m3增加与血管性痴呆:HR=1.004(高度提示,II级)。
- 妊娠中期PM10每1 μg/m3增加与产后抑郁:OR=1.023(高度提示,II级);短期二氧化硫每1 μg/m3增加与精神分裂症复发:暴露后5天RR=1.005、7天RR=1.004(高度提示,II级)。
临床怎么用
- 临床可关注空气污染与气候变化暴露作为精神障碍及自杀行为的潜在可改变风险因素。
- 对痴呆、产后抑郁、精神分裂症复发及自杀风险人群,可结合环境暴露信息进行风险评估与健康教育。
- 证据支持将环境干预纳入人群心理健康促进和公共卫生行动。
局限性
- 多数关联效应量较小,需谨慎解读个体水平临床意义。
- 仅12个关联(5.0%)达到令人信服或高度提示证据级别,其余证据强度较弱。
- 气候变化危害相关证据相对较少(42个关联,17.7%),且多聚焦温度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The impact of air pollution and climate change on mental health has recently raised strong concerns. However, a comprehensive overview analyzing the existing evidence while addressing relevant biases is lacking. This umbrella review systematically searched the PubMed/Medline, Scopus and PsycINFO databases (up to June 26, 2023) for any systematic review with meta-analysis investigating the association of air pollution or climate change with mental health outcomes. We used the R metaumbrella package to calculate and stratify the credibility of the evidence according to criteria (i.e., convincing, highly suggestive, suggestive, or weak) that address several biases, complemented by sensitivity analyses. We included 32 systematic reviews with meta-analysis that examined 284 individual studies and 237 associations of exposures to air pollution or climate change hazards and mental health outcomes. Most associations (n=195, 82.3%) involved air pollution, while the rest (n=42, 17.7%) regarded climate change hazards (mostly focusing on temperature: n=35, 14.8%). Mental health outcomes in most associations (n=185, 78.1%) involved mental disorders, followed by suicidal behavior (n=29, 12.4%), access to mental health care services (n=9, 3.7%), mental disorders-related symptomatology (n=8, 3.3%), and multiple categories together (n=6, 2.5%). Twelve associations (5.0%) achieved convincing (class I) or highly suggestive (class II) evidence. Regarding exposures to air pollution, there was convincing (class I) evidence for the association between long-term exposure to solvents and a higher incidence of dementia or cognitive impairment (odds ratio, OR=1.139), and highly suggestive (class II) evidence for the association between long-term exposure to some pollutants and higher risk for cognitive disorders (higher incidence of dementia with high vs. low levels of carbon monoxide, CO: OR=1.587; higher incidence of vascular dementia per 1 μg/m3 increase of nitrogen oxides, NOx: hazard ratio, HR=1.004). There was also highly suggestive (class II) evidence for the association between exposure to airborne particulate matter with diameter ≤10 μm (PM10) during the second trimester of pregnancy and the incidence of post-partum depression (OR=1.023 per 1 μg/m3 increase); and for the association between short-term exposure to sulfur dioxide (SO2) and schizophrenia relapse (risk ratio, RR=1.005 and 1.004 per 1 μg/m3 increase, respectively 5 and 7 days after exposure). Regarding climate change hazards, there was highly suggestive (class II) evidence for the association between short-term exposure to increased temperature and suicide- or mental disorders-related mortality (RR=1.024), suicidal behavior (RR=1.012), and hospital access (i.e., hospitalization or emergency department visits) due to suicidal behavior or mental disorders (RR=1.011) or mental disorders only (RR=1.009) (RR values per 1°C increase). There was also highly suggestive (class II) evidence for the association between short-term exposure to increased apparent temperature (i.e., the temperature equivalent perceived by humans) and suicidal behavior (RR=1.01 per 1°C increase). Finally, there was highly suggestive (class II) evidence for the association between the temporal proximity of cyclone exposure and severity of symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (r=0.275). Although most of the above associations were small in magnitude, they extend to the entire world population, and are therefore likely to have a substantial impact. This umbrella review classifies and quantifies for the first time the global negative impacts that air pollution and climate change can exert on mental health, identifying evidence-based targets that can inform future research and population health actions.
引用
- Radua J, De Prisco M, Oliva V, et al. Impact of air pollution and climate change on mental health outcomes: an umbrella review of global evidence. World Psychiatry. 2024. PMID: 38727076. doi:10.1002/wps.21219
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。