基于电子健康记录为退伍军人重性抑郁障碍制定个体化治疗规则
本研究使用退伍军人健康管理局初级保健精神卫生整合诊所的43,470例开始重性抑郁障碍治疗的门诊患者电子健康记录,构建包含5,865个基线预测变量的个体化治疗规则(ITR),以12个月内严重负性事件复合指标为结局。结果显示基线预测变量与结局风险显著相关(AU-ROC=0.68,S.E.=0.01),ITR判定56.0%的患者心理治疗为最优治疗,且实施该ITR对总体治疗费用变化可忽略。
要点
- 基线预测变量可区分12个月内严重负性事件风险(AU-ROC=0.68)。
- ITR判定56.0%患者心理治疗最优,风险较其他治疗低约20%。
- 实施ITR后抗抑郁药处方减少16.1%,心理治疗增加2.9%。
核心结论
- 基于电子健康记录构建的个体化治疗规则可识别重性抑郁障碍患者的最优治疗类型,心理治疗对56.0%的患者为最优选择。
- 该个体化治疗规则需实用性试验确认准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 概念验证研究,使用退伍军人健康管理局初级保健精神卫生整合诊所43,470例开始重性抑郁障碍治疗的门诊患者电子健康记录。
- 使用电子健康记录和地理空间数据库生成5,865个基线预测变量,采用最佳实践方法调整非随机治疗分配,在70%训练样本中估计个体化治疗规则,在30%测试样本中评估。
主要发现
- 结局为12个月内至少一次严重负性事件(自杀未遂、精神科急诊就诊、精神科住院、自杀死亡)的复合指标。
- 基线预测变量与结局总体概率显著相关(AU-ROC=0.68,S.E.=0.01)。
- 测试样本中预测风险最高的5%患者结局发生率为32.6%,其余患者为7.1%。
- 个体化治疗规则判定心理治疗仅对56.0%的患者为最优治疗,其结局风险较接受其他治疗低约20%;对其他患者治疗类型与结局风险无关。
- 实施该个体化治疗规则后,抗抑郁药处方患者减少16.1%,接受心理治疗患者增加2.9%,总体治疗费用变化可忽略。
关键数值与推荐
- 个体化治疗规则判定心理治疗仅对56.0%的患者为最优治疗,其结局风险较其他治疗低约20%。
- 预测风险最高的5%患者12个月内严重负性事件发生率为32.6%,其余测试样本患者为7.1%。
- 实施个体化治疗规则后抗抑郁药处方减少16.1%,心理治疗增加2.9%。
临床怎么用
- 可利用电子健康记录数据构建的个体化治疗规则辅助判断重性抑郁障碍患者是否优先接受心理治疗。
- 该工具尚需实用性试验验证后方可用于临床决策。
局限性
- 本研究为概念验证研究,个体化治疗规则的准确性需实用性试验确认。
- 分析基于观察性电子健康记录数据,需采用方法调整非随机治疗分配。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Efforts to develop an individualized treatment rule (ITR) to optimize major depressive disorder (MDD) treatment with antidepressant medication (ADM), psychotherapy, or combined ADM-psychotherapy have been hampered by small samples, small predictor sets, and suboptimal analysis methods. Analyses of large administrative databases designed to approximate experiments followed iteratively by pragmatic trials hold promise for resolving these problems. The current report presents a proof-of-concept study using electronic health records (EHR) of n = 43,470 outpatients beginning MDD treatment in Veterans Health Administration Primary Care Mental Health Integration (PC-MHI) clinics, which offer access not only to ADMs but also psychotherapy and combined ADM-psychotherapy. EHR and geospatial databases were used to generate an extensive baseline predictor set (5,865 variables). The outcome was a composite measure of at least one serious negative event (suicide attempt, psychiatric emergency department visit, psychiatric hospitalization, suicide death) over the next 12 months. Best-practices methods were used to adjust for nonrandom treatment assignment and to estimate a preliminary ITR in a 70% training sample and to evaluate the ITR in the 30% test sample. Statistically significant aggregate variation was found in overall probability of the outcome related to baseline predictors (AU-ROC = 0.68, S.E. = 0.01), with test sample outcome prevalence of 32.6% among the 5% of patients having highest predicted risk compared to 7.1% in the remainder of the test sample. The ITR found that psychotherapy-only was the optimal treatment for 56.0% of patients (roughly 20% lower risk of the outcome than if receiving one of the other treatments) and that treatment type was unrelated to outcome risk among other patients. Change in aggregate treatment costs of implementing this ITR would be negligible, as 16.1% fewer patients would be prescribed ADMs and 2.9% more would receive psychotherapy. A pragmatic trial would be needed to confirm the accuracy of the ITR.
引用
- Zainal NH, Bossarte RM, Gildea SM, et al. Developing an individualized treatment rule for Veterans with major depressive disorder using electronic health records. Mol Psychiatry. 2024. PMID: 38486050. doi:10.1038/s41380-024-02500-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。