单模态与多模态神经影像技术在精神病分类中的荟萃分析与系统综述
该研究系统检索并荟萃分析了93项使用机器学习分类精神分裂症谱系障碍与健康对照的神经影像研究,涵盖T1、DTI、静息态功能连接(rs-FC)及多模态方法。总体分类效应量为OR=2.64(95%CI=2.33至2.95),各模态间分类性能相似,仅在外部数据集中rs-FC较T1有微小优势,多模态与单模态无显著差异。研究间异质性大且存在发表偏倚迹象。
要点
- 所有神经影像模态均能可靠区分精神分裂症谱系障碍与对照,总体OR=2.64(95%CI=2.33至2.95)。
- 各模态分类性能相似,外部数据集中rs-FC较T1有微小优势,多模态与单模态无显著差异。
- 研究间异质性大,漏斗图和Egger检验提示显著偏倚,需更多外部预测和大样本研究。
核心结论
- 神经影像方法在精神病分类中有前景,但目前大多数模态分类性能相似,rs-FC在部分特定情况下较结构模态有微小优势。
- 多模态与单模态方法之间未发现显著差异,rs-FC与单模态研究的分类性能 largely 重叠。
研究设计与样本
- 系统荟萃分析,检索Ovid MEDLINE、PubMed、PsychInfo、Google Scholar和Web of Science从建库至2023年3月13日的文献。
- 纳入标准包括全脑分析和交叉验证,共识别93项研究进行定量综述(30项T1、9项DTI、40项rs-FC、14项多模态)。
- 对同一数据集的研究预测结果进行平均,并运行纳入多数据集合并样本的平行分析,通过漏斗图不对称评估偏倚,使用双变量回归模型检验影像模态、人口学和预处理方法的调节作用。
主要发现
- 所有模态整体上可靠区分精神分裂症谱系障碍与对照,OR=2.64(95%CI=2.33至2.95)。
- 独立内部数据分类中各模态间无差异,外部数据集中rs-FC研究较T1研究有微小优势。
- 结果存在大量异质性,漏斗图和Egger检验显示显著偏倚迹象;限制异质性较小的研究后结果相似,rs-FC相对结构测量仍保持微小优势。
- 所有情况下多模态与单模态方法之间无显著差异,rs-FC与单模态研究分类性能 largely 重叠。
- 人口学和分析或去噪方法的差异与分类评分变化无关。
关键数值与推荐
- 纳入标准包括全脑分析和交叉验证,以全面反映大规模脑系统在精神病中的预测能力。
- 分类效应量以OR=2.64(95%CI=2.33至2.95)表示所有模态整体区分精神分裂症谱系障碍与对照的能力。
临床怎么用
- 当前证据不支持多模态神经影像在精神病分类中优于单模态方法,临床选择模态时可考虑rs-FC在外部预测中的微小优势。
- 需谨慎解读现有分类性能,因研究间异质性大且存在偏倚迹象,建议开展更多外部预测和大样本研究。
局限性
- 研究间存在大量异质性,漏斗图和Egger检验提示显著偏倚。
- 需要更多使用外部预测和大样本量的研究,采用更严格和系统化的标准。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Psychotic disorders are characterized by structural and functional abnormalities in brain networks. Neuroimaging techniques map and characterize such abnormalities using unique features (e.g., structural integrity, coactivation). However, it is unclear if a specific method, or a combination of modalities, is particularly effective in identifying differences in brain networks of someone with a psychotic disorder. METHODS: A systematic meta-analysis evaluated machine learning classification of schizophrenia spectrum disorders in comparison to healthy control participants using various neuroimaging modalities (i.e., T1-weighted imaging (T1), diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), resting state functional connectivity (rs-FC), or some combination (multimodal)). Criteria for manuscript inclusion included whole-brain analyses and cross-validation to provide a complete picture regarding the predictive ability of large-scale brain systems in psychosis. For this meta-analysis, we searched Ovid MEDLINE, PubMed, PsychInfo, Google Scholar, and Web of Science published between inception and March 13th 2023. Prediction results were averaged for studies using the same dataset, but parallel analyses were run that included studies with pooled sample across many datasets. We assessed bias through funnel plot asymmetry. A bivariate regression model determined whether differences in imaging modality, demographics, and preprocessing methods moderated classification. Separate models were run for studies with internal prediction (via cross-validation) and external prediction. RESULTS: 93 studies were identified for quantitative review (30 T1, 9 DTI, 40 rs-FC, and 14 multimodal). As a whole, all modalities reliably differentiated those with schizophrenia spectrum disorders from controls (OR = 2.64 (95%CI = 2.33 to 2.95)). However, classification was relatively similar across modalities: no differences were seen across modalities in the classification of independent internal data, and a small advantage was seen for rs-FC studies relative to T1 studies in classification in external datasets. We found large amounts of heterogeneity across results resulting in significant signs of bias in funnel plots and Egger's tests. Results remained similar, however, when studies were restricted to those with less heterogeneity, with continued small advantages for rs-FC relative to structural measures. Notably, in all cases, no significant differences were seen between multimodal and unimodal approaches, with rs-FC and unimodal studies reporting largely overlapping classification performance. Differences in demographics and analysis or denoising were not associated with changes in classification scores. CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study suggest that neuroimaging approaches have promise in the classification of psychosis. Interestingly, at present most modalities perform similarly in the classification of psychosis, with slight advantages for rs-FC relative to structural modalities in some specific cases. Notably, results differed substantially across studies, with suggestions of biased effect sizes, particularly highlighting the need for more studies using external prediction and large sample sizes. Adopting more rigorous and systematized standards will add significant value toward understanding and treating this critical population.
引用
- Porter A, Fei S, Damme KSF, et al. A meta-analysis and systematic review of single vs. multimodal neuroimaging techniques in the classification of psychosis. Mol Psychiatry. 2023. PMID: 37563277. doi:10.1038/s41380-023-02195-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。