把「精神」放回「精神障碍」:来自恐惧与焦虑研究的视角
本文从恐惧与焦虑研究出发指出,精神健康问题常包含主观意识体验与行为生理反应两类症状群,而行为生理反应因可客观测量在治疗开发与疗效评估中被过度强调。数十年焦虑障碍研究显示行为生理症状与主观体验的相关性不如通常假设的那样强,以客观症状为标记开发的治疗有效性大多令人失望。鉴于「精神」障碍依其主观精神特质命名和定义,作者认为被边缘化主观精神特质的治疗尤其不有效或许并不意外,并指出如今意识认知神经科学研究蓬勃发展,提供了可行且新颖的科学路径,有助于更深入理解精神障碍及其治疗。
要点
- 精神健康问题常同时包含主观意识体验与行为生理反应两类症状群。
- 焦虑障碍数十年研究显示行为生理症状与主观体验的相关性不如通常假设的那样强。
- 以客观症状为标记开发的治疗有效性大多令人失望,主观精神特质不应被边缘化。
核心结论
- 鉴于「精神」障碍依其主观精神特质命名和定义,被边缘化主观精神特质的治疗尤其不有效或许并不意外。
- 行为生理症状与主观体验的相关性不如通常假设的那样强,以客观症状为标记开发的治疗有效性大多令人失望。
- 如今意识认知神经科学研究蓬勃发展,提供了可行且新颖的科学路径,有助于更深入理解精神障碍及其治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为来自恐惧与焦虑研究的视角性文章,未报告系统检索范围或样本量。
主要发现
- 精神健康问题常包含主观意识体验以及行为和(或)生理反应两类症状群。
- 行为生理反应因可客观测量,在治疗开发与疗效评估中被过度强调。
- 临床上临床访谈中患者报告的主观体验常被视为精神病理的弱相关指标。
- 数十年焦虑障碍研究显示,行为生理症状与主观体验的相关性不如通常假设的那样强。
- 以更客观症状为精神病理标记所开发的治疗,有效性大多令人失望。
关键数值与推荐
- 本文未报告具体数值、阈值或推荐等级。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Mental health problems often involve clusters of symptoms that include subjective (conscious) experiences as well as behavioral and/or physiological responses. Because the bodily responses are readily measured objectively, these have come to be emphasized when developing treatments and assessing their effectiveness. On the other hand, the subjective experience of the patient reported during a clinical interview is often viewed as a weak correlate of psychopathology. To the extent that subjective symptoms are related to the underlying problem, it is often assumed that they will be taken care of if the more objective behavioral and physiological symptoms are properly treated. Decades of research on anxiety disorders, however, show that behavioral and physiological symptoms do not correlate as strongly with subjective experiences as is typically assumed. Further, the treatments developed using more objective symptoms as a marker of psychopathology have mostly been disappointing in effectiveness. Given that "mental" disorders are named for, and defined by, their subjective mental qualities, it is perhaps not surprising, in retrospect, that treatments that have sidelined mental qualities have not been especially effective. These negative attitudes about subjective experience took root in psychiatry and allied fields decades ago when there were few avenues for scientifically studying subjective experience. Today, however, cognitive neuroscience research on consciousness is thriving, and offers a viable and novel scientific approach that could help achieve a deeper understanding of mental disorders and their treatment.
引用
- Taschereau-Dumouchel V, Michel M, Lau H, et al. Putting the "mental" back in "mental disorders": a perspective from research on fear and anxiety. Mol Psychiatry. 2022. PMID: 35079126. doi:10.1038/s41380-021-01395-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。