心理治疗对伴或不伴广场恐怖的惊恐障碍的疗效与可接受性比较:随机对照试验的系统综述与网络Meta分析
该系统综述与网络Meta分析纳入136项随机对照试验,比较心理治疗对惊恐障碍急性期的疗效与可接受性。与常规治疗相比,认知行为治疗(CBT)疗效的标准化均数差为-0.67(95%CI -0.95至-0.39),短期心理动力治疗为-0.61(95%CI -1.15至-0.07)。剔除高偏倚风险试验后仅CBT仍优于常规治疗。作者认为CBT和短期心理动力治疗是合理的一线选择。
要点
- 与常规治疗相比,CBT疗效的标准化均数差为-0.67(95%CI -0.95至-0.39),证据置信度为中等。
- 与常规治疗相比,短期心理动力治疗疗效的标准化均数差为-0.61(95%CI -1.15至-0.07),证据置信度为低。
- 剔除高偏倚风险试验后,仅CBT仍比常规治疗更有效。
核心结论
- CBT和短期心理动力治疗是合理的一线选择。
- 高偏倚风险的研究倾向于夸大治疗的总体疗效。
- 该系统综述与网络Meta分析结果应为临床医生和指南提供参考。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与网络Meta分析,纳入136项随机对照试验。
- 检索MEDLINE、Embase、PsycInfo和CENTRAL,从建库至2021年1月1日。
- 采用Cochrane和PRISMA指南,使用随机效应模型进行配对和网络Meta分析,采用CINeMA评估证据置信度。
- 方案已在同行评议期刊发表并注册于PROSPERO(CRD42020206258)。
主要发现
- 疗效分析纳入7352名参与者,可接受性分析纳入6862名参与者。
- 与常规治疗相比,CBT疗效的标准化均数差为-0.67(95%CI -0.95至-0.39;CINeMA:中等),可接受性的相对风险为1.21(95%CI -0.94至1.56;CINeMA:中等)。
- 与常规治疗相比,短期心理动力治疗疗效的标准化均数差为-0.61(95%CI -1.15至-0.07;CINeMA:低),可接受性的相对风险为0.92(95%CI 0.54至1.54;CINeMA:中等)。
- 剔除高偏倚风险试验后,仅CBT仍比常规治疗更有效。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为CBT和短期心理动力治疗是惊恐障碍伴或不伴广场恐怖急性期的合理一线选择。
局限性
- 高偏倚风险的研究倾向于夸大治疗的总体疗效。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Psychotherapies are the treatment of choice for panic disorder, but which should be considered as first-line treatment is yet to be substantiated by evidence. AIMS: To examine the most effective and accepted psychotherapy for the acute phase of panic disorder with or without agoraphobia via a network meta-analysis. METHOD: We conducted a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) to examine the most effective and accepted psychotherapy for the acute phase of panic disorder. We searched MEDLINE, Embase, PsycInfo and CENTRAL, from inception to 1 Jan 2021 for RCTs. Cochrane and PRISMA guidelines were used. Pairwise and network meta-analyses were conducted using a random-effects model. Confidence in the evidence was assessed using Confidence in Network Meta-Analysis (CINeMA). The protocol was published in a peer-reviewed journal and in PROSPERO (CRD42020206258). RESULTS: We included 136 RCTs in the systematic review. Taking into consideration efficacy (7352 participants), acceptability (6862 participants) and the CINeMA confidence in evidence appraisal, the best interventions in comparison with treatment as usual (TAU) were cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) (for efficacy: standardised mean differences s.m.d. = -0.67, 95% CI -0.95 to -0.39; CINeMA: moderate; for acceptability: relative risk RR = 1.21, 95% CI -0.94 to 1.56; CINeMA: moderate) and short-term psychodynamic therapy (for efficacy: s.m.d. = -0.61, 95% CI -1.15 to -0.07; CINeMA: low; for acceptability: RR = 0.92, 95% CI 0.54-1.54; CINeMA: moderate). After removing RCTs at high risk of bias only CBT remained more efficacious than TAU. CONCLUSIONS: CBT and short-term psychodynamic therapy are reasonable first-line choices. Studies with high risk of bias tend to inflate the overall efficacy of treatments. Results from this systematic review and network meta-analysis should inform clinicians and guidelines.
引用
- Papola D, Ostuzzi G, Tedeschi F, et al. Comparative efficacy and acceptability of psychotherapies for panic disorder with or without agoraphobia: systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Br J Psychiatry. 2022. PMID: 35049483. doi:10.1192/bjp.2021.148
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。