文献速递烧伤创面修复

激光多普勒成像的谜题第二部分:深度不确定烧伤,人工还是机器?

The LDI Enigma Part II: Indeterminate depth burns, man or machine?
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2021-06-01

该研究通过问卷和深度访谈调查了全球51家烧伤中心,其中27家(53%)完整回答了32个问题。结果显示89%的中心认为激光多普勒成像(LDI)主要或几乎完全准确;对于LDI中间颜色(粉、黄、绿)的烧伤,76%的中心基于其他因素做决策,最终治疗决策多结合LDI与临床评估(74%)。结论认为LDI减少临床深度不确定烧伤,但中间深度烧伤的治疗决策需结合人工解读与机器测量。

要点

  • LDI被89%的中心认为主要或几乎完全准确。
  • 74%的中心最终治疗决策基于LDI与临床评估结合。
  • 76%的中心对LDI中间颜色烧伤基于其他因素决策。

核心结论

  • LDI减少临床深度不确定烧伤的数量,但中间深度烧伤的治疗决策需结合人工解读与LDI测量。

研究设计与样本

  • 对全球51家烧伤中心进行问卷和深度访谈的调查研究,其中27家(53%)几乎完整回答了32个问题。

主要发现

  • 临床评估与LDI不一致时,41%更依赖临床诊断,25%延迟手术决定,16%次日重新扫描。
  • 对LDI中间颜色(粉、黄、绿),76%基于其他因素决策:%TBSA、一般健康状况、年龄、烧伤部位、定植/感染潜力、患者偏好、依从性、后勤和社会经济因素。

临床怎么用

  • 在临床深度不确定烧伤中,使用LDI辅助早期治疗决策,但需结合临床评估。
  • 对LDI中间颜色烧伤,需综合考虑其他因素(如%TBSA、年龄、部位等)进行决策。

局限性

  • 仅53%的中心完整回答问卷,可能存在应答偏倚。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Laser Doppler imaging is universally considered the most evidence-based method for objective burn depth assessment by accurately predicting burn wound healing potential. This study has analyzed how exactly laser Doppler imaging measurements can be useful in the early therapeutic decision making for patients with clinically indeterminate depth burns. MATERIAL AND METHODS: An extensive survey, by questionnaire and in-depth interviews, was conducted among 51 burn centers worldwide to gain insight on the practical use of laser Doppler imaging. RESULTS: Twenty-seven (53%) of the 51 burn centers contacted almost completely answered the 32 questions. Fifty-two percent of these centers (14/27) had at least 10 years of laser Doppler imaging experience. laser Doppler imaging was considered to be mainly or almost completely accurate by 89%. In case of discrepancy between clinical assessment and LDI, 41% relied more on clinical diagnosis, 25% delayed decision to operate, while 16% re-scanned the next day. The centers most experienced with laser Doppler imaging (13%) relied on it more. Final decisions for treatment were based on the combination of laser Doppler imaging and clinical assessment by 74%. Seventy percent of the centers almost never operated burns with laser Doppler imaging-red and would almost always operate burns with LDI-blue. Treatment decisions for intermediate laser Doppler imaging colors (pink, yellow and green) varied, with 76% basing decisions on other factors: % Total Body Surface Area (TBSA), general health, age, location of the burn, potential for colonization/infection, patient preference, compliance with aftercare, logistics, and socio-economic factors. CONCLUSION: Laser Doppler imaging reduces the number of clinical indeterminate depth burns. For these intermediate depth burns on laser Doppler imaging, treatment decisions are based on a combination of interpretation ('man') and laser Doppler imaging measurements ('machine'). Thorough knowledge of confounding factors and validated laser Doppler imaging color code, consideration of surrounding laser Doppler imaging colors, the use of mean flux values, and not directly burn related factors are essential. Burn centers with most laser Doppler imaging experience considered laser Doppler imaging an indispensable diagnostic tool.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Claes KEY, Hoeksema H, Robbens C, et al. The LDI Enigma Part II: Indeterminate depth burns, man or machine? Burns. 2021. PMID: 34696950. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2021.01.015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。