开放式鼻整形后翻修术:252例经验与风险因素分析
该研究回顾性纳入252例开放式鼻整形后需美学翻修的患者,翻修率为10.8%。最常见翻修原因为鼻尖旋转不足(37.7%)、鼻小柱下垂(30.2%)和鼻尖上区畸形(28.6%); Logistic回归显示支撑杆移植较舌槽技术增加鼻尖旋转不足风险5.3倍,术前鼻尖投影不足增加2倍;年龄>40岁增加鼻小柱下垂风险6.8倍,支撑杆移植较舌槽技术增加5.9倍;支撑杆移植较舌槽技术增加鼻尖上区畸形风险2.2倍。
要点
- 翻修率10.8%,鼻尖旋转不足、鼻小柱下垂、鼻尖上区畸形为前三原因
- 支撑杆移植较舌槽技术显著增加鼻尖旋转不足、鼻小柱下垂及鼻尖上区畸形风险
- 高龄(>40岁)及术前鼻尖投影低者宜选舌槽技术或适度过度旋转鼻尖
核心结论
- 开放式鼻整形后翻修率为10.8%,支撑杆移植及高龄、术前鼻尖投影不足是主要风险因素。
- 对高龄、鼻尖投影及旋转不足者,宜采用舌槽技术或适度过度旋转鼻尖以降低翻修风险。
- 对高龄(>40岁)且术前鼻唇角小者,用舌槽技术替代支撑杆移植可能减少鼻尖上区畸形和鼻小柱下垂。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入252例开放式鼻整形后接受美学翻修的患者。
- 分析翻修前鼻部畸形与术前鼻形态及所用手术技术的统计学关系。
- 证据等级:风险,III级。
主要发现
- 翻修率为10.8%。
- 最常见美学翻修原因为鼻尖旋转不足(37.7%)、鼻小柱下垂(30.2%)、鼻尖上区畸形(28.6%)。
- 支撑杆移植较舌槽技术使鼻尖旋转不足风险增加5.3倍,术前鼻尖投影不足使其增加2倍。
- 年龄>40岁使鼻小柱下垂风险增加6.8倍,支撑杆移植较舌槽技术使其增加5.9倍。
- 支撑杆移植较舌槽技术使鼻尖上区畸形风险增加2.2倍。
关键数值与推荐
- 鼻尖旋转不足:37.7%;鼻小柱下垂:30.2%;鼻尖上区畸形:28.6%。
- 支撑杆移植vs舌槽技术:鼻尖旋转不足风险增加5.3倍;鼻小柱下垂增加5.9倍;鼻尖上区畸形增加2.2倍。
- 年龄>40岁:鼻小柱下垂风险增加6.8倍。
- 术前鼻尖投影不足:鼻尖旋转不足风险增加2倍。
临床怎么用
- 术前评估高龄(>40岁)、鼻尖投影不足及鼻唇角小者,优先考虑舌槽技术。
- 对高风险患者可适度过度旋转鼻尖以降低翻修率。
- 谨慎选择支撑杆移植,权衡鼻尖旋转不足、鼻小柱下垂及鼻尖上区畸形风险。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计,证据等级为III级。
- 单中心252例样本,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: In this study, patients who required aesthetic revision surgery after open rhinoplasty were retrospectively screened for risk factors. METHODS: Two hundred fifty-two patients who underwent revision were included in the study. Nasal deformities before the revision were determined for each patient and evaluated in terms of their statistical relationship with preoperative nasal morphology and surgical techniques used. RESULTS: The revision rate was found to be 10.8 percent. The three most common aesthetic reasons for revision were insufficient nasal tip rotation (37.7 percent), hanging columella (30.2 percent), and supratip deformity (28.6 percent). According to logistic regression analysis, the use of a strut increased the risk of inadequate nasal tip rotation by 5.3-fold compared to the tongue-in-groove technique, whereas inadequate nasal tip projection before surgery increased this risk by 2-fold. Being older than 40 years increased the risk of hanging columella by 6.8-fold, whereas the use of strut grafting instead of the tongue-in-groove technique increased this risk by 5.9-fold. The use of strut grafts instead of the tongue-in-groove technique increased the risk of supratip deformity by 2.2-fold. CONCLUSIONS: To ensure adequate nasal tip rotation after surgery in patients with advanced age and low nasal tip projection and rotation, it will be more appropriate to either use the tongue-in-groove technique or rotate the nasal tip more than normal. In patients with advanced age (>40 years) and low nasolabial angle before surgery, the use of tongue-in-groove technique instead of strut grafting may be advantageous for reducing the incidence of supratip and hanging columella. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Risk, III.
引用
- Sibar S, Findikcioglu K, Pasinlioglu B, et al. Revision Rhinoplasty after Open Rhinoplasty: Lessons from 252 Cases and Analysis of Risk Factors. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2021. PMID: 34550928. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000008318
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。