816例连续烧伤创面活检用于烧伤深度分类的组织学算法
该前瞻性多中心研究基于816例烧伤创面活检,迭代构建并验证组织学烧伤活检算法(BBA)。20%创面被临床团队误判为需切除植皮。研究强调附件结构坏死比真皮外观更重要。
要点
- BBA将烧伤创面分为一度、浅二度、深二度和三度四类。
- 临床团队对20%的创面误判为需切除植皮。
- 附件结构坏死比真皮外观对判断愈合潜力更重要。
核心结论
- 基于客观组织学标准的BBA可用于烧伤深度评估,其临床误分类率与既往文献一致。
主要发现
- BBA分类:7%一度、13%浅二度、43%深二度、37%三度。
- 20%烧伤创面被临床团队误判为需切除植皮。
关键数值与推荐
- 一度和浅二度视为可能无需手术愈合,深二度和三度视为21天内不太可能愈合。
- 活检由皮肤病理学家使用H&E全切片扫描评估表皮、乳头真皮、网状真皮存在与否及坏死附件结构比例。
临床怎么用
- BBA可辅助临床医生进行烧伤深度评估,减少不必要手术或治疗延迟。
- 组织学评估应重视附件结构坏死而非仅真皮外观。
局限性
- H&E无法评估乳头和网状真皮活力。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Burn experts are only 77% accurate when subjectively assessing burn depth, leaving almost a quarter of patients to undergo unnecessary surgery or conversely suffer a delay in treatment. To aid clinicians in burn depth assessment (BDA), new technologies are being studied with machine learning algorithms calibrated to histologic standards. Our group has iteratively created a theoretical burn biopsy algorithm (BBA) based on histologic analysis, and subsequently informed it with the largest burn wound biopsy repository in the literature. Here, we sought to report that process. This was an IRB-approved, prospective, multicenter study. A BBA was created a priori and refined in an iterative manner. Patients with burn wounds assessed by burn experts as requiring excision and autograft underwent 4 mm biopsies procured every 25 cm2. Serial still photos were obtained at enrollment and at excision intraoperatively. Burn biopsies were histologically assessed for presence/absence of epidermis, papillary dermis, reticular dermis, and proportion of necrotic adnexal structures by a dermatopathologist using H&E with whole slide scanning. First degree and superficial second degree were considered to be burn wounds likely to have healed without surgery, while deep second- and third-degree burns were considered unlikely to heal by 21 days. Biopsy pathology results were correlated with still photos by five burn experts for consensus of final burn depth diagnosis. Sixty-six subjects were enrolled with 117 wounds and 816 biopsies. The BBA was used to categorize subjects' wounds into four categories: 7% of burns were categorized as first degree, 13% as superficial second degree, 43% as deep second degree, and 37% as third degree. Therefore, 20% of burn wounds were incorrectly judged as needing excision and grafting by the clinical team as per the BBA. As H&E is unable to assess the viability of papillary and reticular dermis, with time our team came to appreciate the greater importance of adnexal structure necrosis over dermal appearance in assessing healing potential. Our study demonstrates that a BBA with objective histologic criteria can be used to categorize BDA with clinical misclassification rates consistent with past literature. This study serves as the largest analysis of burn biopsies by modern day burn experts and the first to define histologic parameters for BDA.
引用
- Phelan HA, Holmes Iv JH, Hickerson WL, et al. Use of 816 Consecutive Burn Wound Biopsies to Inform a Histologic Algorithm for Burn Depth Categorization. J Burn Care Res. 2021. PMID: 34387313. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irab158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。