整形外科文献中的伦理代表性:系统综述
本系统综述检索8个文献数据库,纳入过去十年讨论整形外科伦理问题的同行评议文章531篇(初检7097篇)。结果显示自主原则出现于87.9%的文章,知情同意与面部移植为最常见议题,美容外科讨论最多(占29.8%);作者结论为伦理讨论发文量约增5倍,但各伦理原则代表性不均、部分亚专科明显不足。
要点
- 自主原则在87.9%的纳入文章中出現,代表性最高,公正原则仅51.2%。
- 知情同意与面部移植是讨论最多的议题。
- 美容外科占全部纳入文章的29.8%,为伦理讨论最多的亚专科。
核心结论
- 过去十年含伦理讨论的整形外科发文约增5倍,反映学界伦理意识增强。
- 伦理原则的代表性仍不均衡,部分整形外科亚专科明显代表性不足。
- 整形外科医生在临床与研究中阐述伦理问题时应采用更全面的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索8个文献数据库,识别过去十年讨论整形外科伦理问题的同行评议文章。
- 初检共识别7097篇文章,最终531篇纳入分析。
- 由独立评审者提取纳入文章的特征与伦理原则。
主要发现
- 自主原则出现于87.9%的文章,为代表性最高的伦理原则。
- 有利原则出现于74.4%、不伤害原则72.3%、公正原则51.2%的文章。
- 知情同意与面部移植是讨论最普遍的议题。
- 美容外科为伦理讨论最多的亚专科,占全部纳入文章的29.8%。
临床怎么用
- 临床与研究中的伦理阐述应覆盖自主、有利、不伤害、公正四项原则,避免仅侧重自主与知情同意。
- 在伦理讨论不足的亚专科中加强伦理议题的识别与发表。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: A 2009 systematic review demonstrated that ethical discourse was underrepresented in the plastic surgery literature; approximately one in 1000 articles contained ethical discussions. In the decade since, advances in plastic surgery and continued social progress have created new ethical dilemmas. However, it is unclear whether these developments have augmented the representation of ethics in the plastic surgery literature. A review of publications over the past decade can assess whether progress has been made and identify where deficits persist. METHODS: The authors searched eight bibliographic databases to identify peer-reviewed articles discussing ethical issues in plastic surgery over the past decade. Independent reviewers extracted characteristics and ethical principles from included articles. RESULTS: A total of 7097 articles were identified from the initial search and 531 articles were included for analysis. The principle of autonomy, present in 87.9 percent of articles, had the greatest representation, followed by beneficence (74.4 percent), nonmaleficence (72.3 percent), and justice (51.2 percent). Informed consent and face transplantation were the most prevalent topics discussed. Aesthetic surgery was the subdiscipline of plastic surgery with the greatest ethical discourse, representing 29.8 percent of all included articles. CONCLUSIONS: In the past decade, there was approximately a five-fold increase in plastic surgery publications that include ethical discourse, indicating a growing awareness of ethical implications by the plastic surgery community. However, representation of ethical principles remained uneven, and specific subdisciplines of plastic surgery were substantially underrepresented. Plastic surgeons should adopt a more comprehensive approach when framing ethical implications in clinical and research settings.
引用
- Chappell AG, Kane RL, Wood SM, et al. Representation of Ethics in the Plastic Surgery Literature: A Systematic Review. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2021. PMID: 34228030. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000008232
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。