TikTok美容手术视频质量分析:DISCERN量表评估
本研究用DISCERN量表评估TikTok上鼻整形、眼睑整形、隆乳和腹壁整形视频的质量。四类手术总体平均DISCERN评分均对应极差质量(鼻整形1.55、眼睑整形1.44、隆乳1.25、腹壁整形1.29),医生视频评分显著高于非医生视频,喜剧类评分最低、教育类最高。
要点
- TikTok美容手术视频整体质量极差,DISCERN均分1.25–1.55(满分5)。
- 医生制作的视频DISCERN评分显著高于非医疗人员制作的视频。
- 喜剧类视频评分最低,教育类视频评分最高。
核心结论
- TikTok上鼻整形、眼睑整形、隆乳和腹壁整形视频的总体平均DISCERN评分对应极差质量。
- 医生制作的视频DISCERN评分显著高于非医疗人员制作的视频。
- 喜剧类视频平均DISCERN评分最低,教育类视频最高。
研究设计与样本
- 研究检索TikTok移动应用中鼻整形、眼睑整形、隆乳和腹壁整形相关内容。
- 由两名独立评审者按DISCERN量表(1–5分)分析视频质量。
- 比较医生与非医生创作者视频、不同内容类别视频的评分差异。
主要发现
- 视频创作者中医生占56%,非医疗人员占44%。
- 鼻整形平均DISCERN评分为1.55,眼睑整形为1.44,隆乳为1.25,腹壁整形为1.29。
- 医生视频的DISCERN评分在所有手术中均显著高于非医生视频。
- 喜剧类视频平均DISCERN评分最低,教育类视频最高。
关键数值与推荐
- DISCERN量表评分范围1–5分,分数越高信息质量越好。
- 鼻整形平均DISCERN评分1.55,眼睑整形1.44,隆乳1.25,腹壁整形1.29。
临床怎么用
- 医疗专业人员应参与在TikTok上创建高质量信息。
- 应向患者说明社交媒体上存在错误信息,以支持健康素养。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: TikTok is one of the most popular and fastest-growing social media apps in the world. Previous studies have analyzed the quality of patient education information on older video platforms, but the quality of plastic and cosmetic surgery videos on TikTok has not yet been determined. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to analyze the source and quality of certain cosmetic procedure videos on TikTok. METHODS: The TikTok mobile application was queried for content related to 2 popular face procedures (rhinoplasty and blepharoplasty) and 2 body procedures (breast augmentation and abdominoplasty). Two independent reviewers analyzed video content according to the DISCERN scale, a validated, objective instrument that assesses the quality of information on a scale of 1 to 5. Quality scores were compared between videos produced by medical and nonmedical creators and between different content categories. RESULTS: The included videos attracted 4.8 billion views and 76.2 million likes. Videos were created by medical doctors (56%) and laypersons (44%). The overall average DISCERN score out of 5 corresponded to very poor video quality for rhinoplasty (1.55), blepharoplasty (1.44), breast augmentation (1.25), and abdominoplasty (1.29). DISCERN scores were significantly higher among videos produced by doctors than by laypersons for all surgeries. Comedy videos consistently had the lowest average DISCERN scores, whereas educational videos had the highest. CONCLUSIONS: It is increasingly important that medical professionals understand the possibility of patient misinformation in the age of social media. We encourage medical providers to be involved in creating quality information on TikTok and educate patients about misinformation to best support health literacy.
引用
- Om A, Ijeoma B, Kebede S, et al. Analyzing the Quality of Aesthetic Surgery Procedure Videos on TikTok. Aesthet Surg J. 2021. PMID: 34297053. doi:10.1093/asj/sjab291
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。