烧伤切除与植皮系统综述:低收入与高收入国家早期与晚期手术结局比较
该系统综述与荟萃分析比较低收入国家(LIC)与高收入国家(HIC)烧伤患者早期与晚期切除植皮的结局。纳入16项合格试验,结果显示早期切除在两类国家均缩短住院时间并减少脓毒症,但晚期切除死亡率更低,尤其在HIC老年患者中。数据定义异质性大,对LIC早期切除的作用尚无法得出准确结论。
要点
- 早期切除在LIC与HIC均缩短住院时间并减少脓毒症。
- 晚期切除在LIC与HIC死亡率均低于早期切除,HIC老年患者亚组分析证实此点。
- 年龄、切除时机、%TBSA比较及吸入伤纳入等定义异质,数据解释困难。
核心结论
- 早期切除在LIC与HIC均缩短LOS并减少脓毒症,但晚期切除死亡率更低。
- 因数据定义异质,无法就LIC早期切除的作用得出准确结论,需前瞻性研究。
研究设计与样本
- 遵循PRISMA指南与MOOSE清单的系统综述与荟萃分析。
- 检索1990至2017年英文文献,数据库为Web of Science、Cochrane协作网与PubMed。
- 从278条引文经全文评估41篇后纳入16项合格试验,用Newcastle-Ottawa量表评价质量。
主要发现
- 早期切除较晚期切除在LIC与HIC均缩短住院时间。
- 晚期切除较早期切除在LIC与HIC死亡率均更低。
- HIC老年患者亚组分析确认晚期切除死亡率更低,排除老年人后死亡率无变化。
- 早期切除在LIC与HIC均减少脓毒症。
临床怎么用
- 在资源有限环境中决策切除时机需权衡缩短LOS与减少脓毒症的获益及死亡率风险。
- 对老年烧伤患者应审慎评估早期切除的死亡风险。
局限性
- 年龄、切除时机定义不一,%TBSA比较方式各异。
- 吸入伤与合并症纳入混杂,资源可及性未量化,数据难以解释。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: While the benefits of early excision in burn surgery are clear, the advantages may be lost in low income countries with limited resources. It is important to identify the right timing of excision in different groups of patients, particularly those in low-income countries (LIC), as the burden of disease contributes to the highest global mortality and has the least resources. This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to determine the timing of excision in LICs and the outcomes associated with surgery: (1) mortality, (2) sepsis and (3) length of stay (LOS) compared to high income countries (HICs). METHODOLOGY: The PRISMA guidelines and MOOSE checklist were followed for this review. Publications in English from year 1990 to 2017 that included data on the timing and type of burn surgery and outcomes were included. Searches were done using Web of Science, Cochrane collaboration and Pubmed using keywords "Burn and surgery", "Burn and excision", "Burn and excision and grafting" and "burn and skin grafting". Trial quality was evaluated using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale. Outcomes compared for early and late excisions were length of stay (LOS), sepsis and mortality between LICs and HICs. RESULTS: From 278 citations, we selected 41 for full text evaluation, and identified 16 eligible trials. LOS is shorter in early excision compared to late excision in both LICs and HICs. Mortality is lower in late excision compared to early excision in both LICs and HICs. Further subgroup analysis of elderly patients in HICs confirmed that mortality is lower in late excision and unchanged if the elderly are excluded. Early excision reduces sepsis in both LIC and HIC. DISCUSSION: The variable definitions of age, timing of excision, variable nature of % TBSA comparison, mixed inclusion of inhalation injury, co-morbidities and unquantified access to resources make the data difficult to interpret and it is not possible to draw accurate conclusions on the role of early excision for burns in low-middle income countries. A prospective study is needed in order to answer this question.
引用
- Wong L, Rajandram R, Allorto N, et al. Systematic review of excision and grafting in burns: Comparing outcomes of early and late surgery in low and high-income countries. Burns. 2021. PMID: 34303572. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2021.07.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。