美容整形外科医生对风险认知的调查
该研究向Aesthetic Society会员发放24项调查,评估其对三种非主流术式的风险认知。189份完整回复显示,分别有50%、49%、89%的医生不开展填充剂鼻整形、脂肪移植丰臀和颌下腺切除术,主要顾虑为患者安全。与文献数据相比,医生对不熟悉术式的严重并发症风险存在高估,且培训中缺乏相关接触。
要点
- 半数以上医生不开展填充剂鼻整形和脂肪移植丰臀,89%不开展颌下腺切除术。
- 不开展的主要原因是担心患者安全,且培训中未学习这些术式。
- 医生对不熟悉术式的严重并发症风险存在高估。
核心结论
- 整形外科医生对不熟悉术式的风险认知高于文献报告的严重并发症率,这种认知及培训缺乏可能导致回避这些术式。
研究设计与样本
- 向Aesthetic Society会员发放24项调查,聚焦填充剂鼻整形、脂肪移植丰臀和颌下腺切除术三种术式,共回收189份完整问卷。
主要发现
- 50%的医生不开展填充剂鼻整形,49%不开展脂肪移植丰臀,89%不开展颌下腺切除术。
- 不开展这些术式的医生中多数将「患者安全」列为主要顾虑。
- 绝大多数医生报告未在培训中学习这些术式。
- 医生认为腹壁成形术和乳房增大-乳房固定术等更常见术式的风险显著更低且更可接受。
临床怎么用
- 医生应意识到对不熟悉术式的风险感知可能高于文献数据,避免因高估风险而回避安全术式。
- 培训中应增加对新型或非主流术式的暴露,以改善风险认知。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: With continuous innovation in plastic surgery, new procedures are constantly being introduced. A number of these procedures are generally safe but have the potential for rare yet serious complications. Many surgeons steer clear of these procedures due to safety concerns. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this paper was to survey the membership of The Aesthetic Society to elicit perception of risk of several novel or less mainstream procedures. METHODS: A 24-item survey was sent out to members of The Aesthetic Society. The survey focused on surgeon experience and attitude towards 3 procedures: filler rhinoplasty, gluteal augmentation with fat grafting, and submandibular gland excision. RESULTS: In total, 189 completed surveys were returned. Of the responders, 50%, 49%, and 89% of surgeons said they do not perform filler rhinoplasty, gluteal augmentation with fat grafting, or submandibular gland excision in their practices, respectively. The majority of those who do not perform the procedures selected "danger to the patient" as the primary concern for each of the 3 procedures. Surgeons overwhelmingly reported not learning these procedures in training. Additionally, surgeons perceive the risks of more common procedures such as abdominoplasty and breast augmentation-mastopexy to be significantly lower and more acceptable than those of the studied procedures. CONCLUSIONS: When comparing the perceived complication rates with data published in the literature, particularly when looking at rates of serious or life-threatening complications, plastic surgeons overestimate the risks of procedures with which they are less familiar. This perception of risk, accompanied by the lack of exposure to novel techniques in training, may contribute to surgeons avoiding these procedures.
引用
- Sherif RD, Lisiecki J, Gilman RH, et al. Perception of Risk Among Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons. Aesthet Surg J. 2021. PMID: 33725722. doi:10.1093/asj/sjab132
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。