虚拟手术计划与实际结果的一致性:五种颅颌面术式比较
本研究比较了同一术者实施的五种颅颌面术式的虚拟手术计划与实际术后结果的一致性。结果显示,植入物颅骨修补和下颌骨重建一致性最高,正颌手术和下颌骨牵引次之,颅顶重塑最低(组间p<0.001)。
要点
- 植入物颅骨修补与下颌骨重建的虚拟计划一致性最高。
- 涉及大幅骨移动或术后移动的术式(下颌牵引、非刚性颅顶重塑)一致性较低。
- 一致性较低的术式仍可通过术中判断获得良好结果。
核心结论
- 虚拟手术计划用于定制永久植入物和术中导板时结果更可预测,而涉及更高程度骨骼重定位和术后移动的术式一致性较低。
研究设计与样本
- 将虚拟手术计划的立体光刻格式与术后CT扫描比较,通过布尔运算计算感兴趣区域的一致性百分比。
- 使用方差分析和事后Bonferroni分析比较不同术式的一致性。
主要发现
- 植入物颅骨修补一致性中位数76.8±10.3%,下颌骨重建均值69.4±11.2%。
- 正颌手术均值55.0±7.3%,下颌骨牵引中位数41.9±20.3%。
- 颅顶重塑均值22.2±12.1%,组间p<0.001,组内p>0.05。
临床怎么用
- 对于定制植入物和导板辅助的术式,虚拟手术计划可提供较高可预测性。
- 对于预期一致性较低的术式,应依靠术中判断以获得良好结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The "accuracy" of virtual surgical planning across multiple procedure types is not known. The authors aimed to compare the planned outcome from virtual surgical planning to the actual postoperative outcome for five craniofacial procedure types performed by a single surgeon: implant cranioplasty, cranial vault remodeling, orthognathic surgery, mandible reconstruction, and mandibular distraction. METHODS: Stereolithography formats were obtained from virtual surgical planning and compared to postoperative computed tomographic scans for consecutive patients who underwent one of the five procedure types. Volumetric renderings of the operated bony region of interest were overlaid and compared using a Boolean operation to compute conformity (as a percentage of the region of interest). Conformity across procedure type was analyzed using analysis of variance and post hoc Bonferroni analysis, where appropriate. RESULTS: One hundred thirty patients were included (51.5 percent male and 49.5 percent female; mean age, 27 years; 59 orthognathic surgery, 32 cranial vault remodeling, 16 mandible reconstruction, 12 mandibular distraction, and 11 implant cranioplasty patients). The highest tier of conformity was obtained for implant cranioplasty (median, 76.8 ± 10.3 percent) and mandible reconstruction (mean, 69.4 ± 11.2 percent), followed by orthognathic surgery (mean, 55.0 ± 7.3 percent) and mandibular distraction (median, 41.9 ± 20.3 percent), followed by cranial vault remodeling (mean, 22.2 ± 12.1 percent) (p < 0.001 between tiers and p > 0.05 among tiers). CONCLUSIONS: Virtual surgical planning resulting in custom permanent implants and intraoperative guides provides more predictable results compared to virtual surgical planning used for procedures involving higher degrees of skeletal repositioning and postoperative movement (i.e., mandibular distraction and nonrigid cranial vault remodeling). In cases with expectedly lower conformity, excellent outcomes can be achieved with sound intraoperative judgment.
引用
- Maniskas S, Pourtaheri N, Chandler L, et al. Conformity of the Virtual Surgical Plan to the Actual Result Comparing Five Craniofacial Procedure Types. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2021. PMID: 33776034. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000007776
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。