严重烧伤急诊管理转诊标准的依从性研究
这项回顾性多中心队列研究纳入2014至2018年荷兰西南创伤区及Brabant急救网络收治的1790例烧伤患者,评估其转诊与收治是否符合EMSB转诊标准。首诊于非烧伤中心的951例中666例(70.0%)符合标准管理,265例(27.9%)符合标准却未转诊;烧伤中心收治的1213例中1119例(92.3%)符合标准。电烧伤与化学烧伤的依从性最低。
要点
- 首诊非烧伤中心患者总体依从性70.0%,但27.9%符合标准者未转诊
- 烧伤中心收治患者中92.3%符合转诊标准
- 电烧伤(14.3%)与化学烧伤(42.1%)依从性最低,是改进重点
核心结论
- 非烧伤中心首诊患者对EMSB转诊标准总体依从性较高,但约四分之一符合标准者未被转诊至烧伤中心。
- 电烧伤与化学烧伤的单项标准依从性最低,是主要改进方向。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性、多中心队列研究,纳入2014至2018年荷兰西南创伤区及Network Emergency Care Brabant收治的烧伤患者共1790例。
- 结局指标为对EMSB转诊标准的依从性。
主要发现
- 951例首诊于非烧伤中心,其中666例(70.0%)按转诊标准管理:263例(27.7%)恰当地未转诊,403例(42.4%)恰当地转诊。
- 20例(2.1%)过度转诊,265例(27.9%)符合标准却未转诊(转诊不足)。
- 烧伤中心收治的1213例中1119例(92.3%)符合转诊标准。
- 依从性最低为电烧伤(N=4;14.3%)和化学烧伤(N=16;42.1%),最高为「儿童烧伤面积≥5% TBSA」(N=109;83.2%)。
关键数值与推荐
- EMSB转诊标准依从性:非烧伤中心首诊患者70.0%(666/951)。
- 恰当未转诊27.7%(263/951),恰当转诊42.4%(403/951),过度转诊2.1%(20/951),转诊不足27.9%(265/951)。
- 烧伤中心收治患者符合标准比例92.3%(1119/1213)。
- 电烧伤依从14.3%(N=4),化学烧伤依从42.1%(N=16),儿童≥5% TBSA烧伤依从83.2%(N=109)。
临床怎么用
- 接诊烧伤患者时应按EMSB标准逐条核对转诊指征,尤其避免符合标准却未转诊。
- 对电烧伤和化学烧伤患者应强化标准执行与转诊决策。
- 非烧伤中心可通过培训与流程优化减少转诊不足。
局限性
- 为回顾性研究,依从性判断依赖病历记录。
- 电烧伤(N=4)和化学烧伤(N=16)样本量小,单项依从性估计可能不稳定。
- 研究限于荷兰两个区域网络,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The primary aim was to determine to what extent referral and admission of burn patients to a hospital with or without a burn center was in line with the EMSB referral criteria. METHODS: This was a retrospective, multicenter cohort study. Burn patients admitted from 2014 to 2018 to a hospital in the Southwest Netherland trauma region and Network Emergency Care Brabant were included in this study. Outcome measures were the adherence to the EMSB referral criteria. RESULTS: A total of 1790 patients were included, of whom 951 patients were primarily presented to a non-burn center. Of these patients, 666 (70.0%) were managed according to the referral criteria; 263 (27.7%) were appropriately not referred, 403 (42.4%) were appropriately referred. Twenty (2.1%) were overtransferred, and 265 (27.9%) undertransferred. In 1213 patients treated at a burn center 1119 (92.3%) met the referral criteria. Adherence was lowest for electrical (N = 4; 14.3%) and chemical burns (N = 16; 42.1%), and was highest in 'children ≥5% total body surface area (TBSA) burned' (N = 109; 83.2%). CONCLUSION: The overall adherence to the referral criteria of patients presented to a non-burn center was fairly high. However, approximately 25% was not transferred to a burn center while meeting the criteria. Most improvement for individual criteria can be achieved in patients with electrical and chemical burns.
引用
- Van Yperen DT, Van Lieshout EMM, Nugteren LHT, et al. Adherence to the emergency management of severe burns referral criteria in burn patients admitted to a hospital with or without a specialized burn center. Burns. 2021. PMID: 33707084. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2021.02.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。