林顿·A·惠特克的传承:培养颅颌面外科领军者
该研究通过分析惠特克医生培养的颅颌面及整形外科受训者的职业成就,回顾其传承。1980至2011年间共34名颅颌面fellowship及11名整形外科住院医完成培训,多数从事颅颌面临床(83.3%)和学术工作(78.0%),平均发表76篇论文,H指数18,学术晋升比例高。
要点
- 1980-2011年共45名受训者完成颅颌面或整形培训,多数从事颅颌面临床(83.3%)和学术(78.0%)工作。
- 受训者平均发表76篇论文、23篇章节、H指数18、获13项基金。
- 进入学术界的受训者中53.1%晋升正教授,75.0%主持颅颌面项目,53.1%任主任/主席。
核心结论
- 惠特克医生的临床贡献与其培养的受训者的成功同等重要,后者将继续传承培养下一代颅颌面外科领军者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入1980至2011年间在惠特克担任项目主任时完成颅颌面fellowship或担任主任时完成住院医培训的受训者,共34名fellowship和11名住院医加fellowship,复习简历并分析地理分布、执业类型、学术领导职位、学术作品和文献计量数据。
主要发现
- 83.3%的受训者培训后从事颅颌面临床实践,78.0%在学术机构执业。
- 31.1%在东北部执业,31.1%在南部,分布全国24个州。
- 平均发表论文76±81篇(范围2-339),书籍章节23±29(0-135),H指数18±12(1-45),基金13±16(0-66)。
- 追求学术者中,53.1%晋升正教授,46.9%担任项目主任,75.0%主持颅颌面项目,53.1%达到主任/主席级别。
临床怎么用
- 颅颌面外科培训项目可参考惠特克模式,注重培养学术领导力和临床实践能力。
- 受训者职业成就可作为评估培训项目效果的指标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Linton A. Whitaker is a pioneer of craniofacial surgery. He served as chief of plastic surgery at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and University of Pennsylvania and director of the craniofacial training program. Herein, the authors reflect on his legacy by studying the accomplishments of his trainees. METHODS: Dr Whitaker's trainees who completed (a) craniofacial fellowship training while he was director of the program or (b) residency training while he was chief were identified. Curricula vitae were reviewed. Variables analyzed included geographic locations, practice types, academic leadership positions, scholarly work, and bibliometric data. RESULTS: Between 1980 and 2011, 34 surgeons completed craniofacial fellowship training under Dr Whitaker, and 11 completed plastic surgery training under his chairmanship and subsequent craniofacial fellowship. The majority had active craniofacial practices after training (83.3%) and practice in an academic setting (78.0%). Most settled in the northeast (31.1%) and south (31.1%) but across 24 states nationally. Overall, the mean ± SD number of publications was 76 ± 81 (range, 2-339); book chapters, 23 ± 29 (0-135); H-index, 18 ± 12 (1-45); and grants, 13 ± 16 (0-66). Of those who pursued academia, 53.1% were promoted to full professor, 46.9% had a program director role, 75.0% directed a craniofacial program, and 53.1% achieved the rank of chief/chair. CONCLUSIONS: Equally important to Dr Whitaker's clinical contributions in plastic and craniofacial surgery is the development and success of his trainees who will undoubtedly continue the legacy of training the next generation of craniofacial surgeon leaders.
引用
- Azoury SC, Kalmar CL, Zimmerman CE, et al. The Linton A. Whitaker Legacy: Cultivating Craniofacial Surgeon Leaders. Ann Plast Surg. 2021. PMID: 33555679. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002742
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。