单阶段与早期两阶段腭裂修复术后言语与听力学结局比较
结果显示两组在所有言语参数上无显著差异,但两阶段组鼓膜置管次数更多(相对风险1.74,P=0.009)且首次置管年龄更小(4.5月 vs 16.9月,P=0.012)。结论认为两种术式在言语和听力结局上无显著差异,支持根据医生和家庭偏好选择手术时机。
要点
- 单阶段与两阶段腭裂修复在言语参数上无显著差异
- 两阶段修复鼓膜置管次数增加(RR=1.74,P=0.009)
- 两阶段修复首次置管年龄更小(4.5月 vs 16.9月)
核心结论
- 单阶段与两阶段腭裂修复在言语和听力结局上无显著差异,支持根据医生和家庭偏好选择手术时机。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病历 review,纳入2006至2012年诊断为唇裂伴完全性腭裂并接受单阶段或两阶段修复的患者,共84例。
主要发现
- 单阶段组腭裂修复平均年龄13.3个月;两阶段组软腭和硬腭修复平均年龄分别为4.2个月和11.8个月。
- 单阶段与两阶段修复在所有言语参数(包括过高鼻音、过低鼻音、鼻漏气、构音、表达性语言、接受性语言、言语清晰度和言语可接受度)上无显著差异,无论单侧或双侧唇腭裂。
- 两阶段修复与鼓膜置管次数增加相关(相对风险1.74;P=0.009),且首次置管年龄更小(两阶段组4.5个月 vs 单阶段组16.9个月,P=0.012),87.5%的置管在修复第一阶段完成。
- 两组在末次随访听力图上的听力损失类型、程度或至少轻度传导性听力损失的存在与否无差异。
临床怎么用
- 临床可根据医生和家庭偏好选择单阶段或两阶段腭裂修复时机,因言语和听力结局无显著差异。
- 两阶段修复需注意鼓膜置管次数可能增加,应加强中耳功能监测。
局限性
- 回顾性研究设计可能存在选择偏倚和信息偏倚。
- 样本量有限(84例),可能影响统计效能。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The timing and management of patients with cleft palates have been controversial. Early soft palate closure at the time of cleft lip repair followed by hard palate closure at a second stage has been hypothesized to improve speech and audiology outcomes. This study compares cleft palate patients who have undergone single-stage versus 2-stage cleft palate repairs and the outcomes on speech and hearing. METHODS: A retrospective chart review identified patients with diagnosis of cleft lip with complete cleft palate who underwent either single or 2-stage repair from 2006 to 2012. Data collected included age at each surgery, necessity of further speech surgery for velopharyngeal insufficiency, frequency of tympanostomy tube placement, presence of hearing loss, and speech assessment data graded per the validated Americleft speech scale. RESULTS: A total of 84 patients were identified and subdivided into groups of single-stage and 2-stage repair. The mean age at the time of single-stage palate repair was 13.3 months. For the 2-stage group, the mean ages were 4.2 and 11.8 months for the soft palate and hard palate repairs, respectively. Comparing the single-stage versus 2-stage palate repairs, there was no significant difference in all speech parameters including hypernasality, hyponasality, nasal air emission, articulation, expressive language, receptive language, speech intelligibility, and speech acceptability for both unilateral and bilateral cleft lip/palate patients. Two-stage repair was associated with increased number of tympanostomy tube placement compared with single-stage repair (relative risk, 1.74; P = 0.009), and the first set of tubes was performed at a statistically significantly younger age, 4.5 months in the 2-stage repair compared with 16.9 months in the single-stage (P = 0.012) with 87.5% performed with first stage of repair. However, there was no difference in the types, degrees of hearing loss, or the presence of at least mild conductive hearing loss at latest follow-up audiograms between the groups. CONCLUSIONS: There was no significant benefit with respect to speech or hearing outcomes between single-stage and 2-stage cleft palate repairs. This advocates for surgeon and family preference in the timing of cleft palate repair.
引用
- Crowley JS, Friesen TL, Gabriel RA, et al. Speech and Audiology Outcomes After Single-Stage Versus Early 2-Stage Cleft Palate Repair. Ann Plast Surg. 2021. PMID: 33559999. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002747
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。