静态图像中加入已知物体对烧伤面积估算准确性的影响
该研究在模型不同部位绘制模拟烧伤区域,用iPhone 5s拍摄照片并分别加入手掌、银行卡和硬币作为参照物,由烧伤团队成员估算烧伤百分比。结果显示总体高估烧伤面积,前臂小面积估算较好,但加入标准物体未改善准确性,背部面积高估最明显。
要点
- 静态图像总体高估烧伤面积,加入参照物未改善准确性。
- 前臂小面积估算较准,误差在1.1%以内。
- 背部相同大小面积高估范围达0.9%–8.9%。
核心结论
- 静态图像倾向于高估烧伤面积,即使图像中包含标准参照物体也未改善估算准确性。
研究设计与样本
- 在模型不同身体部位绘制模拟烧伤区域,用iPhone 5s拍摄照片,分别加入手掌、标准银行卡和硬币作为参照物,由烧伤团队成员观察30张照片并估算烧伤百分比。
主要发现
- 总体存在烧伤面积高估。
- 前臂小面积估算较好,在计算表面积的1.1%以内。
- 前臂图像中加入标准物体未改善估算。
- 背部面积高估最明显,范围0.9%–8.9%,尽管所有模拟面积大小相同。
临床怎么用
- 临床中应意识到仅凭静态图像估算烧伤面积可能高估,尤其背部区域。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Currently information regarding burn size from referring departments to burn centres varies in accuracy. Inaccurate assessment of burn size can lead to over or under treatment. Photographs of injuries may improve accuracy of assessment. We aimed to assess the accuracy of measuring burn size on a static image by including a standard object in the image. METHODS: Simulated burn areas were drawn on different body parts of the model. Using an iPhone® model 5 s with an 8 megapixel camera we took photos of the marked area, and repeated them with the palm, a standard bank card and a penny in the picture. First the Du Bois formula, was used to calculate body surface area. Members of the Burns team were asked to view the photos (n = 30) and estimate the percentage of the simulated burn. RESULTS: We found an overall overestimation of burn size. Small areas of the forearm were better estimated and within 1.1% of the calculated surface area, however we found no improvement when using a standard object in these images. The back areas were most overestimated ranging from 0.9%-8.9% despite all being the same sized area. CONCLUSIONS: Static images tend to overestimate burn size despite the use of a standard object in the image.
引用
- Smith K, Poterlowicz K, Southern S, et al. The effect of a known object in a static image of a burn to improve the burn size estimation. Burns. 2021. PMID: 33495039. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.12.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。