美容外科研究资金来源与去向:谁获得资助?
该研究回顾了2009至2019年《Aesthetic Surgery Journal》的2262篇论文,其中318篇为资助论文。92%的研究获外部资助,主要来自私营企业(66%),且84%的资助研究来自学术机构;私营执业机构更依赖企业资助(87% vs 55%,P=0.001),研究经费来源的多样性不足或可解释美容与重建外科研究间的差距。
要点
- 美容外科研究资助主要来自私营企业,占66%,基金会/学会、政府资助分别占18%和8%。
- 84%的资助研究来自学术机构,私营执业机构仅占14%。
- 私营执业机构研究更依赖企业资助(87% vs 55%,P=0.001),基金会/学会、政府等资助比例更低。
核心结论
- 私营执业外科医生研究经费来源缺乏多样性,可能解释当前美容与重建外科研究间的差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性文献分析,纳入2009至2019年《Aesthetic Surgery Journal》的2262篇论文,其中318篇资助论文符合标准,采用卡方检验、t检验、双变量及多变量回归分析。
主要发现
- 294篇(92%)研究获外部资助,其中281篇(88%)仅由外部资金支持。
- 外部资助来源:私营企业194篇(66%)、基金会/学会53篇(18%)、政府资助23篇(8%)、多机构组合24篇(8%)。
- 资助研究机构分布:学术机构266篇(84%)、私营执业46篇(14%)、私营企业6篇(2%)。
- 学术机构研究比例逐年上升,与私营执业研究减少相关(r=-0.95,r²=0.89,P<0.001)。
- 私营执业机构比学术机构更依赖企业资助(87% vs 55%,P=0.001),基金会/学会(2% vs 20%)、政府(0% vs 9%)、组合(7% vs 8%)、内部部门(4% vs 8%)资助比例更低。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应关注研究资助来源对研究多样性的影响,并促进私营执业机构获取多元化资助。
- 私营执业机构可寻求基金会、政府等非企业资助以平衡研究经费来源。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recent data show that aesthetic surgery research is lagging compared with reconstructive surgery: research funding and institutional disparities within aesthetic surgery are potential factors in this trend. OBJECTIVES: The authors sought to determine if disparities exist in aesthetic surgery research based on funding sources or practice settings. METHODS: The authors reviewed Aesthetic Surgery Journal articles from 2009 to 2019. Chi-square, t test, bivariate, and multivariate regression analyses were employed to evaluate research trends. RESULTS: A total of 2262 publications were identified, with 318 funded articles meeting inclusion criteria. The majority of studies (294, 92%) received external funding, with 281 (88%) being supported solely by external funds. Externally funded studies were financed by private industry (194, 66%), foundations/societies (53, 18%), government grants (23, 8%), or a combination of agencies (24, 8%). The majority of funded studies were at academic institutions (266, 84%), followed by private practice (46, 14%) and private industry (6, 2%). Analysis of annual publications revealed a rising percentage of academic-based research, which correlated with decreasing research from private practice (r = -0.95, r2 = 0.89, P < 0.001). Compared with academic institutions, private practice relied more heavily on industry funding (55% vs 87%, respectively, P = 0.001), exhibiting lower rates of foundational/societal (20% vs 2%), governmental (9% vs 0%), combined (8% vs 7%), and internal department funding (8% vs 4%). Article citations and level of evidence were unaffected by funding source, agency, or practice setting. CONCLUSIONS: Lack of diversity in research funding among private practice surgeons may explain the reported discrepancies that currently exist between aesthetic and reconstructive surgery research.
引用
- Hammond JB, Armstrong VL, McMullen K, et al. Aesthetic Surgery Research Funding: Where Does It Come From and to Whom Does It Go? Aesthet Surg J. 2021. PMID: 33252613. doi:10.1093/asj/sjaa335
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。