用临床判断模型理解经验证疼痛评估工具对烧伤ICU医护与成年患者的影响:多方法研究
该多方法研究在烧伤ICU连续70例患者中比较引入CPOT、NRS和PAINAD前后镇痛镇静用药及转归,并访谈12名医护与12名患者。结果显示干预后吗啡(P=0.04)与丙泊酚(P=0.04)用量显著增加,对乙酰氨基酚呈增加趋势(P=0.06),通气时间与ICU/住院时长未变。定性分析表明CPOT和NRS增强分析性推理与疼痛倡导,PAINAD显得冗余。
要点
- 引入CPOT与NRS后吗啡和丙泊酚用量显著增加,对乙酰氨基酚呈增加趋势。
- TBSA≥20%者丙泊酚用量显著增加,TBSA<20%者咪达唑仑呈增加趋势。
- 通气时间与ICU/住院时长未因评估工具引入而改变。
核心结论
- 基于证据的疼痛评估实践有助于烧伤ICU的有效疼痛评估、管理与倡导。
研究设计与样本
- 多方法研究:连续病历回顾比较干预前与干预后6个月的连续烧伤患者(n=70)。
- 对ICU医护(n=12)与烧伤成年患者(n=12)进行36次定性访谈,以Tanner(2006)临床判断模型为指导。
主要发现
- 干预后吗啡(P=0.04)与丙泊酚(P=0.04)用量显著增加,对乙酰氨基酚呈增加趋势(P=0.06)。
- TBSA<20%者咪达唑仑用量呈增加趋势(P=0.06),TBSA≥20%者丙泊酚用量显著增加(P=0.03)。
- 通气时间与ICU/住院时长未改变。
- 定性分析显示临床判断依赖患者情境、病房文化、医护背景信念与对患者的了解。
- CPOT与NRS增强分析性推理与疼痛倡导,PAINAD显得冗余。
临床怎么用
- 在烧伤ICU可优先采用CPOT与NRS辅助疼痛评估与疼痛倡导。
- PAINAD在该人群中可能冗余,需结合临床判断使用。
- 评估工具引入后应监测镇痛镇静用药变化,而非仅关注时长指标。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Intensive care (ICU) patients' burn pain is difficult to assess, communicate and address, risking chronic pain syndromes and psychological morbidity. AIMS: To understand how the introduction of validated pain tools (Critical Care Pain Observation Tool [CPOT], Numerical Rating Scale [NRS], Pain Assessment in Advanced Dementia [PAINAD]) affected clinical judgement processes, analgesia/sedation administration and the experience of burn-injured patients. METHODS: Consecutive chart review compared type and amount of analgesia/sedation administered, ventilation time and length of ICU/hospital stay between consecutive burn patients pre- and 6-months post-intervention (n=70). Analysis of 36 qualitative interviews with ICU clinicians (n=12) and burn-injured adults (n=12) pre- and post-intervention was guided by Tanner's (2006) Clinical Judgement Model. RESULTS: Overall, there was a significant increase in morphine (P=0.04) and propofol (P=0.04) use and a trend towards increased paracetamol (P=0.06) use post-intervention. There was a trend towards greater Midazolam use for TBSA<20% (P=0.06), and significantly increased propofol use for TBSA≥20% (P=0.03). Ventilation time and ICU/hospital length of stay were unchanged. Qualitative analysis revealed complex clinical judgement dependent on the context of the patient's situation, unit culture, background beliefs of clinicians and in knowing the patient. Whilst the CPOT and NRS enhanced analytic reasoning and pain advocacy, the PAINAD appeared redundant. CONCLUSIONS: Effective pain assessment, management and advocacy are assisted by evidence-based assessment practices.
引用
- Taggart S, Skylas K, Brannelly A, et al. Using a clinical judgement model to understand the impact of validated pain assessment tools for burn clinicians and adult patients in the ICU: A multi-methods study. Burns. 2020. PMID: 33277094. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.05.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。