烧伤急救手机应用建议与英国烧伤协会指南的对比分析
该研究对Google Play和Apple Store中所有免费英文急救应用进行内容分析,将烧伤急救建议与英国烧伤协会(BBA)的12个维度指南对比评分。103个急救应用中61个包含烧伤治疗信息,平均得分仅3.3/12;85%的应用提出冷却烧伤,但仅11%明确20分钟冷却时长,3%建议伤后3小时内可冷却。结论认为烧伤急救信息在线质量不佳,需改进。
要点
- 免费英文急救应用中仅约六成包含烧伤急救信息,整体质量低。
- 多数应用提及冷却烧伤,但仅少数明确20分钟冷却时长。
- reputable急救慈善机构开发的应用评分同样不理想。
核心结论
- 社区烧伤急救实施不佳,网络及智能设备应用中的烧伤急救信息亟需改进。
研究设计与样本
- 对Google Play和Apple Store中所有免费英文急救应用进行内容分析,并与英国烧伤协会(BBA)12个维度的指南对比评分。
主要发现
- 103个急救应用中61个包含烧伤治疗信息,所有应用平均得分为3.3分(满分12分)。
- 85%的应用提出需要冷却烧伤,但仅11%明确需要冷却20分钟,3%建议伤后3小时内可冷却。
- 知名急救慈善机构开发的应用评分同样不佳。
关键数值与推荐
- BBA指南被拆分为12个维度进行评分,满分12分。
- 85%的应用提及冷却烧伤;11%明确20分钟冷却;3%建议伤后3小时内可冷却。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应知晓患者可能从手机应用获取不准确的烧伤急救信息。
- 可向患者强调烧伤后冷却20分钟等关键急救要点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Many websites giving first aid advice are disappointingly inaccurate and at times dangerous in regard to burn injuries. With more patients relying on their smart phones to obtain online information the aim of this study was to compare first aid applications (apps) burn advice against those guidelines set by the British Burns Association (BBA). METHOD: A content analysis of all freely available English written first aid apps from Google Play and the Apple Store was performed. The information was compared against BBA guidance which was split into 12 domains and scored appropriately. RESULTS: 61 of the 103 first aid apps included in the study, had information on the treatment of burn injuries. The mean score for all apps was 3.3 out of 12. 85% of apps postulated the need to cool the burn. However, only 11% of apps stipulated the need for 20min of cooling, while 3% suggested the burn can be cooled up to 3h post injury. Disappointingly even apps produced by reputable first aid charities scored poorly. CONCLUSION: Burns first aid is documented as being poorly given in the community. With easy access to the internet and specifically smart device apps, more needs to be done to improve burn first aid information online.
引用
- Kilshaw AD, Jivan S. Smartphone apps on burns first aid: A review of the advice. Burns. 2020. PMID: 33279340. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.04.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。