组织工程真皮与人工真皮移植用于指尖重建的潜力
结果显示两种真皮移植均无移植物排斥或失败,组织工程真皮在瘢痕质量上更优,人工真皮手术时间更短、费用更低;两者在术后活动度和感觉恢复上优于皮瓣组,但皮瓣组完全闭合时间更短且术后刺痛感更少。
要点
- 组织工程真皮与人工真皮移植均无排斥或失败,可作为骨外露指尖缺损的重建选择。
- 组织工程真皮在瘢痕质量上优于人工真皮,并可能在感觉不适恢复方面更优。
- 两种真皮移植在术后活动度和两点辨别觉恢复上优于逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣。
核心结论
- 组织工程真皮和人工真皮移植可能是指尖重建的有前景的替代方案。
- 组织工程真皮可能较人工真皮提供更好的功能结果,包括感觉不适恢复和瘢痕质量方面的美学结果。
研究设计与样本
- 组织工程真皮移植组n=71,人工真皮移植组n=23,逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣组n=88。
- 比较指标包括手术时间、住院时长、总费用、成功率、愈合时间、感觉恢复、活动度、瘢痕质量和患者满意度。
主要发现
- 组织工程真皮和人工真皮移植均无移植物排斥或失败;逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣组出现1例部分坏死和1例完全坏死。
- 组织工程真皮在瘢痕质量上更优;人工真皮手术时间更短且手术费用更低。
- 两种真皮移植组在术后活动度、两点辨别觉感觉恢复和住院时长方面均优于逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣组。
- 逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣组完全闭合时间更短且术后刺痛感更少。
- 各组间总体患者满意度无差异。
临床怎么用
- 对于骨外露指尖缺损,可考虑组织工程真皮或人工真皮移植作为逆行指动脉岛状皮瓣的替代方案。
- 若优先考虑瘢痕质量和感觉恢复,组织工程真皮可能更优;若优先考虑手术时间和费用,人工真皮可能更合适。
- 需权衡皮瓣在完全闭合时间和术后刺痛感方面的优势。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Management of skin and soft-tissue defects of the fingertips is functionally and aesthetically important, but controversial, especially when bones are exposed. Recent advances in wound healing technology allow the use of cells or biological dermis. The authors studied the clinical efficacy of tissue-engineered dermis grafts and artificial dermis grafts versus immediate reconstructive procedures, such as the reverse digital artery island flap, in treating bone-exposed fingertip defects. METHODS: One hundred eighty-two patients with bone-exposed fingertip defects treated with tissue-engineered dermis grafts (n = 71), artificial dermis grafts (n = 23), or reverse digital artery island flaps (n = 88) were included in this retrospective cohort study. Surgical time, duration of hospitalization, total cost, success rate, healing time, sensory recovery, range of motion, scar quality, and patient satisfaction were compared. RESULTS: No tissue-engineered or artificial dermis graft exhibited graft rejection or failure, whereas there was one partial loss and one total loss after reverse digital artery island flap surgery. Tissue-engineered dermis grafts were superior in scar quality, and artificial dermis grafts had shorter surgical times and lower surgical costs; both groups demonstrated superior results in postoperative range of motion and sensory recovery in two-point discrimination tests and shorter hospitalization, compared with the reverse digital artery island flap group. The reverse digital artery island flap had shorter complete closure time and less postoperative tingling sensation. There were no differences in overall patient satisfaction among the groups. CONCLUSIONS: Tissue-engineered and artificial dermis grafts may be promising alternatives for fingertip reconstruction. In particular, tissue-engineered dermis grafts may deliver superior functional results, including recovery of sensory discomfort and aesthetic results in terms of scar quality over artificial dermis grafts. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, III.
引用
- Namgoong S, Jung JE, Han SK, et al. Potential of Tissue-Engineered and Artificial Dermis Grafts for Fingertip Reconstruction. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2020. PMID: 32915527. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000007258
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。