自体脂肪隆胸中脂肪干细胞富集对多数求美者适得其反:系统综述
该系统综述检索2008年1月至2019年10月英文和德文文献,纳入23项评估自体脂肪隆胸后脂肪存活率的原始研究,基于报告保留率估算容积获得。结果显示自体脂肪移植(AL)保留率39%–76%,细胞辅助脂肪移植(CAL)最多提高24%;相同采集脂肪量下两次AL的容积获得优于一次CAL。
要点
- AL保留率39%–76%,CAL最多仅提高24%。
- 相同采集脂肪量下,两次AL容积获得优于一次CAL。
- 低BMI求美者分离ASC所需额外脂肪不被保留率提升抵消,两次AL或更优。
核心结论
- 相同采集脂肪量下,两次AL的容积获得远优于一次CAL。
- 对低BMI女性,分离ASC所需额外脂肪未被保留率提升抵消,两次AL可能更利于最大化容积获得。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索2008年1月至2019年10月英文和德文电子数据库文献。
- 纳入所有在体内评估自体脂肪隆胸后脂肪存活率的原始文章,共23项研究。
- 基于报告的保留率估算CAL与AL的潜在容积获得。
主要发现
- AL保留率范围为39%至76%,CAL最多将保留率提高24%。
- 研究人群BMI范围为18.8至23.4(20.4±1.6),同年龄组女性BMI为28.7(±8.4)。
- 从200 ml采集脂肪出发,两次各100 ml的AL后保留容积最多152 ml。
- 一次100 ml的CAL(另100 ml用于分离ASC)后最多保留95 ml脂肪。
临床怎么用
- 对低BMI、寻求自体脂肪隆胸的求美者,可优先考虑两次AL而非一次CAL以最大化容积获得。
- CAL需额外脂肪用于分离ASC,临床决策时应权衡其保留率提升幅度与额外脂肪消耗。
局限性
- 容积获得基于文献报告的保留率估算,非直接测量。
- 仅纳入英文和德文文献,检索截至2019年10月。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Autologous lipotransfer (AL) is a popular method despite unpredictable retention rates. Higher retention rates have been reported when co-administering adipose-derived stem cells (ASCs), a process called cell-assisted lipotransfer (CAL). Our hypothesis is that CAL might indeed limit volume gain in most women seeking aesthetic breast augmentation because it doubles the amount of fat required without consistently improving the outcome. METHODS: Electronic databases were searched for articles published between January 2008 and October 2019 in English and German. All original articles evaluating fat viability following autologous breast augmentation in vivo were included. Based on the reported retention rates, potential volume gains were estimated for CAL and AL. RESULTS: A total of 23 studies were selected. The AL retention rate varied from 39% to 76%, whereas CAL increased this rate at best by 24%. The body mass index (BMI) ranged from 18.8 to 23.4 (20.4±1.6) in the study population, whereas the BMI of women in the same age group is 28.7 (±8.4). We calculated that, starting from 200 ml of harvested fat and after two sessions of AL of 100 ml each, the volume retained would be at most 152 ml. In contrast, after one session of CAL of 100 ml, while the remaining 100 ml are used to isolate ASCs, a maximum of 95 ml of fat would remain. CONCLUSION: The volume gain after two sessions of AL is far superior to that after one session of CAL for the same volume of harvested fat. This is an important practical consideration for women with low BMI, as the extra fat required to isolate ASCs is not counterbalanced by an increase in the retention rate. Therefore, two sessions of AL may be preferable to maximize the volume gain.
引用
- Lutfi D, Turkof E. Adipose-derived stem cell enrichment is counter-productive for the majority of women seeking primary aesthetic breast augmentation by autologous fat transfer: A systematic review. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2020. PMID: 32919950. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2020.08.057
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。