蒸汽吸入:弊大于利?英国烧伤中心的视角
同期全国数据库查询发现201例同类病例。作者认为蒸汽吸入相关烫伤对住院资源和费用影响显著,实际负效应可能远高于本研究所统计的住院病例。
要点
- 蒸汽吸入可导致各年龄段(2周至91岁)的烫伤,多数累及下半身
- 19例患者中6例需手术,占用98次门诊预约,总住院83天
- 估计19例患者治疗总费用超过31872英镑,全国同期发现201例
核心结论
- 蒸汽吸入继发烫伤对住院时长和费用有显著影响,实际负效应可能远高于仅统计住院病例的结果。
- 提高公众对蒸汽吸入风险的认识及一级预防政策可减少此类损伤的发生频率。
研究设计与样本
- 收集数据包括患者人口学特征、烧伤机制、烧伤面积、深度、治疗及相关并发症;同时通过国际烧伤损伤数据库查询同期全国蒸汽吸入烫伤的患病率。
主要发现
- 共识别19例成年和儿童患者,年龄范围2周至91岁。
- 多数患者(16/19,84%)烧伤累及下半身,3例累及胸部或上肢。
- 6例患者接受手术,占用98次门诊预约,总住院天数为83天。
- 估计治疗这19例患者的总费用超过31872英镑。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应认识到蒸汽吸入是各年龄段烫伤的潜在原因,尤其注意下半身烫伤。
- 建议加强公众教育,告知蒸汽吸入的风险,并推动一级预防政策以减少相关损伤。
局限性
- 本研究仅纳入住院患者,未统计门诊或未就医的轻症病例,真实负效应可能被低估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Steam inhalation is common practice in UK households for coryzal symptoms in adults and children. Steam inhalation has the potential to and has caused significant scald injuries, predominantly due to unintentional contact with the hot water used. METHODS: The authors used electronic health records to retrospectively identify all patients admitted with scald injuries secondary to steam inhalation over a 2-year period from January 2018-December 2019 at Chelsea and Westminster Hospital, a regional burns centre. Data collected included patient demographics, mechanism of burn, as well as burn size, depth, treatment and any associated complications. An International Burns Injury Database enquiry assessed the national prevalence steam inhalation scalds over the same time period. RESULTS: 19 adult and paediatric patients were identified in our centre over a 2-year period, with an age range of 2 weeks to 91 years old. The majority (16/19, 84%) of patients received burns to their lower body, with three patients receiving burns to their chest and/or upper limbs. Six patients underwent surgery, 98 clinic appointments were utilised and the total length of hospital stay was 83 days. The estimated total cost of treating these 19 patients was over £31,872. Nationally, 201 cases were identified between Jan 2018-Dec 2019. CONCLUSIONS: Scald injuries secondary to steam inhalation have a significant impact both in terms of hospital stay and cost. Since this study captured only patients admitted to hospital, the true negative impact of steam inhalation is likely to be much higher than calculated. Better public awareness on the risks of steam inhalation and primary prevention policies could reduce the frequency of such injuries.
引用
- Scarborough A, Scarborough O, Abdi H, et al. Steam inhalation: More harm than good? Perspective from a UK burns centre. Burns. 2020. PMID: 32943275. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.08.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。