简易二维图像分析法监测手部增生性瘢痕压力治疗中面积变化
本研究采用相机加三脚架拍摄、免费软件ImageJ分析的简易方法,对4处手部增生性瘢痕在24周压力治疗的8个时间点拍摄,3名操作者各重复分析32幅图像3次。结果显示瘢痕面积测量者内信度ICC为0.943(0.922,0.96),测量者间信度ICC为0.554(0.063,0.795),不同拍摄时间点间差异显著(p<0.05),该方法较VSS更敏感反映瘢痕变化。
要点
- 简易拍照加ImageJ可量化手部增生性瘢痕面积,成本低且易操作。
- 测量者内信度ICC为0.943(0.922,0.96),测量者间信度ICC为0.554(0.063,0.795)。
- 该方法对瘢痕随时间变化的敏感性优于温哥华瘢痕量表(VSS)记录。
核心结论
- 相机加三脚架拍摄配合ImageJ分析的简易二维图像法可经济、较容易地量化手部增生性瘢痕变化,有助于监测治疗进展并提高治疗依从性。
- 该方法测量者内信度好、测量者间信度中等,且较VSS更敏感反映瘢痕状况随时间的变化。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用简易二维图像分析方法,用相机与三脚架拍摄、免费软件ImageJ分析。
- 对4处手部增生性瘢痕样本在24周压力治疗的8个时间点进行拍摄。
- 3名操作者经2小时培训后分析32幅瘢痕图像,测量手部与瘢痕表面积,整个测量重复3次。
主要发现
- 瘢痕表面积测量者内信度ICC为0.943(0.922,0.96),测量者间信度ICC为0.554(0.063,0.795)。
- 重复测量对被试内效应不显著(p>0.05),3名操作者间被试间效应不显著(p>0.05),但不同拍摄时间点间差异显著(p<0.05)。
- 图像分析方法对瘢痕状况随时间的变化比VSS记录更敏感。
临床怎么用
- 可用于手部增生性瘢痕压力治疗期间定期拍照随访,定量追踪瘢痕面积变化。
- 操作者需经培训,建议固定拍摄条件并由同一操作者系列测量以减少操作者间差异。
局限性
- 样本仅4处手部增生性瘢痕,样本量小。
- 测量者间信度仅为中等(ICC 0.554),且未报告VSS对比的具体数值。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Hypertrophic scars are usually evaluated based on scar assessment scales such as Vancouver Scar Scale (VSS) and the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale (POSAS) which are difficult in recording small changes in the scar conditions over time. This study adopts a simple method to quantify the size of hypertrophic scars on hands by using a camera and tripod set-up for image capturing and a free software, ImageJ, for analysis. The ability to record the changes in scars condition and healing progress of this method were investigated. Four hypertrophic scar samples on the hands were captured at 8 time-points during 24-week of pressure therapy. Three operators were trained for 2h to use the software and then carried out image analysis on 32 scar images to obtain the surface areas of the hand and the scars and repeat the entire measurement for 3 times. The results show that the measured scar surface areas have good intra-operator reliability with an intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) of 0.943 (0.922, 0.96) and moderate inter-operator reliability with an ICC of 0.554 (0.063, 0.795). No significant within-subject effect of the repeat of measurements (p>0.05) and between-subject effect of the three operators (p>0.05) were found on the scar area measurements and the proportion of the scars on hands but significant differences were found between different time-points of the image capturing (p<0.05). The image analysis method is more sensitive to the change of scars conditions over time than the VSS record. This is an economical and relatively easy method to quantify the changes in the hypertrophic scars which could be useful for monitoring the progress of therapy and encourage treatment compliance.
引用
- Yu A, Yick KL, Ng SP, et al. A study of using a simple 2D image analysis method to monitor the surface area of hypertrophic scars on hand during pressure therapy. Burns. 2020. PMID: 32499048. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.04.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。