整形外科期刊的替代计量学:与引用次数相关吗?
该研究对6本整形外科期刊2016年全部1420篇文章进行引用分析,发现Altmetric Attention Score(AAS)与引用次数仅呈弱正相关(r=0.33,P<.0001),AAS不宜作为未来引用的准确早期预测指标,两者应联合用于评估学术影响力。
要点
- AAS与引用次数总体弱正相关(r=0.33),不能作为引用次的准确替代指标。
- 高引用前1%文章中AAS与引用强正相关(r=0.64,P=.01)。
- 高AAS前1%文章中AAS与引用无显著相关(r=-0.31,P=.29)。
核心结论
- AAS与引用次数总体相关性弱,可能不是未来引用的准确早期预测指标。
- 两种指标测量学术影响力的不同方面,应联合使用以判断文章传播范围。
研究设计与样本
- 对6本整形外科期刊2016年全年发表的所有文章进行引用分析,共纳入1420篇。
- 提取并分析每篇文章的引用次数与Altmetric Attention Score(AAS)。
主要发现
- 1420篇文章的平均AAS为11,中位AAS为1。
- 平均AAS最高的期刊为Aesthetic Surgery Journal(31),其次为Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery(19)。
- AAS与引用次数呈弱正相关(r=0.33,P<.0001)。
- 引用次数前1%的文章中AAS与引用次数呈强正相关(r=0.64,P=.01)。
- AAS前1%的文章中AAS与引用次数无显著相关(r=-0.31,P=.29)。
临床怎么用
- 评价文章影响力时不应单独依赖AAS预测未来引用,宜将AAS与引用次数联合使用。
- 对高引用潜力的文章,AAS可作为补充传播指标参考。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Altmetrics (alternative metrics) have become one of the most commonly utilized metrics to track the impact of research articles across electronic and social media platforms. OBJECTIVES: The goal of this study was to identify whether the Altmetric Attention Score (AAS) is a good proxy for citation counts and whether it can be employed as an accurate measure to complement the current gold standard. METHODS: The authors conducted a citation analysis of all articles published in 6 plastic surgery journals during the 2016 calendar year. Citation counts and AAS were abstracted and analyzed. RESULTS: A total of 1420 articles were identified. The mean AAS was 11 and the median AAS was 1. The journal with the highest mean AAS was Aesthetic Surgery Journal (31), followed by Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (19). A weak positive correlation was identified (r = 0.33, P < .0001) between AAS and citations. Articles in the top 1% in terms of citation counts showed strong positive correlation between AAS and citation counts (r = 0.64, P = .01). On the contrary, articles in the top 1% of AAS had no significant correlation with citation counts (r = -0.31, P = .29). CONCLUSIONS: Overall correlation between citations and AAS was weak, and therefor AAS may not be an accurate early predictor of future citations. The 2 metrics seem to measure different aspects of the impact of scholarly work and should be utilized in tandem for determining the reach of a scientific article.
引用
- Asaad M, Howell SM, Rajesh A, et al. Altmetrics in Plastic Surgery Journals: Does It Correlate With Citation Count? Aesthet Surg J. 2020. PMID: 32506129. doi:10.1093/asj/sjaa158
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。