局部表面活性剂与局部抗生素在大鼠梳状烧伤模型中的比较
研究在大鼠梳状烧伤模型中比较局部表面活性剂与三重抗生素软膏对烧伤进展的影响。20只大鼠共制作40个梳状烧伤,随机分组每日局部涂抹。7天组织学坏死百分比无差异(85% vs 75%,平均差10%,95%CI -4 to 24),表面活性剂更持久但未减少损伤进展。
要点
- 表面活性剂未减少大鼠梳状烧伤缺血区坏死进展
- 7天组织学坏死百分比两组无显著差异
- 表面活性剂在每日换药时保持完整附着,抗生素已被吸收
核心结论
- 与抗生素软膏相比,局部表面活性剂未减少大鼠梳状烧伤模型中的损伤进展。
研究设计与样本
- 在20只大鼠上制作40个梳状烧伤(4个全层烧伤与3个未烧伤间隔),随机分为每日局部表面活性剂或三重抗生素软膏组。
- 第7天切除标本盲法评估组织学坏死,研究有80%把握度检测第7天坏死间隔百分比25%的差异。
主要发现
- 第7天组织学坏死间隔百分比:表面活性剂组85%(95%CI 74 to 92),抗生素组75%(95%CI 63 to 84),平均差10%(95%CI -4 to 24)。
- 实验7天内任何一天的大体坏死间隔百分比两组均无差异。
- 每日换药时表面活性剂保持完整附着,而抗生素已被吸收。
临床怎么用
- 该动物模型结果不支持用局部表面活性剂替代抗生素软膏来减少烧伤缺血区进展。
- 表面活性剂在创面停留更持久,但持久性未转化为减少坏死进展的获益。
局限性
- 研究为大鼠梳状烧伤模型,结果不能直接外推至人类烧伤。
- 样本量为20只大鼠40个烧伤,仅能检测25%的坏死间隔百分比差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Burn injury progression in the secondary zone of ischemia is common leading to delayed healing and increased scarring. We hypothesized that a topical surfactant, would reduce burn injury progression in a validated rat comb burn model compared with topical antibiotic ointment. METHODS: We created 40 comb burns on 20 rats which were randomized to daily topical application of the surfactant or a triple antibiotic ointment. The comb burns consisted of 4 full thickness burns with 3 unburned interspaces between the 4 burns. These unburned interspaces represented the zone of ischemia, and when left untreated, generally progress to full thickness necrosis within several days. Comb burns were assessed daily for the presence of gross necrosis of the interspaces. At 7 days the comb burns were excised and blindly evaluated for the presence of histological evidence of necrosis. The study had 80% power to detect a 25% difference in the percentages of necrotic interspaces on day 7. RESULTS: There were no differences in the percentages of histologically necrotic interspaces at 7 days in burns treated with the surfactant or antibiotic ointment (85% [95%CI, 74 to 92] vs. 75% [95%CI, 63 to 84]; mean difference 10% [95%CI -4 to 24]). There were also no between group differences in the percentages of grossly necrotic interspaces on any of the seven days of the experiment. The surfactant remained intact and adherent while the antibiotic had been absorbed at each daily dressing change. CONCLUSIONS: A topical surfactant did not reduce injury progression in the rat comb burn model when compared with antibiotic ointment. The surfactant was more durable than the antibiotic ointment.
引用
- Singer AJ, Zhang N, Baer E, et al. Comparison of a topical surfactant and a topical antibiotic in the rat comb burn model. Burns. 2020. PMID: 32534891. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.04.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。