烧伤领域高被引与临床影响力研究的文献计量分析
该研究通过Web of Science检索烧伤相关关键词,筛选出100篇被引次数最高的烧伤论文,并采用混合方法识别导致临床实践改变的论文。100篇高被引论文被引次数在159至907次之间,总被引次数与期刊影响因子、发表年份或主题领域无相关性。23篇临床 influential 研究中6篇不在100篇高被引之列,仅用高被引列表不足以识别烧伤领域领先研究者。
要点
- 烧伤领域100篇高被引论文被引159-907次,与影响因子、年份、主题无关。
- 证据等级不能预测未来被引或临床影响力。
- 23篇临床 influential 研究中6篇不在100篇高被引列表内。
核心结论
- 引文分析是识别里程碑论文的有益工具,但单独使用不足以全面识别,尤其在烧伤等多学科领域。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Web of Science检索烧伤相关关键词,识别100篇被引次数最高的烧伤论文,记录研究设计、发表年份、期刊和主题。
- 采用混合方法识别导致临床实践改变的烧伤研究论文,并将这些论文的特征与高被引论文比较,以分析预测未来被引或临床影响力的因素。
主要发现
- 100篇高被引论文被引次数范围为159至907次。
- 总被引次数与期刊影响因子、发表年份或主题领域之间无相关性。
- 证据等级不能预测未来被引次数或临床影响力,但可能受不断变化的研究标准影响。
- 23篇临床 influential 研究中,有6篇不在100篇被引次数最高的论文列表中。
- 仅使用100篇高被引列表不足以识别烧伤领域的领先研究者。
临床怎么用
- 在烧伤等多学科领域评估研究影响力时,不应仅依赖引文分析,需结合临床实践改变等混合方法。
- 识别领域领先研究者时,需注意高被引列表可能遗漏部分临床 influential 研究。
局限性
- 仅基于Web of Science检索,可能遗漏其他数据库收录的论文。
- 证据等级对影响力的预测可能受不断变化的研究标准影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Although many reviews describe significant advances in burn care, no studies have yet examined why these papers had such profound impact. Our objective was to identify the most highly cited, as well as the most clinically influential studies in burns, and describe their characteristics, to inform future research in the field. Web of Science was searched using keywords related to burns to identify the 100 most-cited burns papers. Study design, year and journal of publication, and subject of the paper were recorded. A mixed-methods approach was used to identify papers in burn research leading to change in clinical practice. Characteristics of these papers were compared with identify any factors predictive of future citations or clinical influence. The 100 highly cited papers were cited between 159 and 907 times. There was no correlation between total citations and journal impact factor, year of publication, or subject area. Level of evidence did not predict future citations or influence, but may be influenced by evolving research standards. Of 23 clinically influential studies, 6 were not among 100 most-cited. Using papers only from the 100 most-cited list was not sufficient to identify leading researchers in burns. Citation analysis is a beneficial, however not alone sufficient to identify landmark papers, particularly for multidisciplinary fields such as burns.
引用
- Ring J, Castanov V, McLaren C, et al. Scientific Impact and Clinical Influence: Identifying Landmark Studies in Burns. J Burn Care Res. 2020. PMID: 32479625. doi:10.1093/jbcr/iraa083
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。