机器人对比传统保留乳头乳晕乳房切除加即刻凝胶假体再造:病例对照研究
单中心病例对照研究比较机器人保留乳头乳晕乳房切除(R-NSM)与传统C-NSM联合即刻凝胶假体乳房再造。R-NSM总体满意度更高(92%优 vs 75.6%优,P=0.046),但手术时间更长、总医疗费用更高(10,877±796 vs 5,702±661美元,P<0.01),NAC缺血坏死风险与总体并发症率无显著差异。
要点
- R-NSM总体满意度显著高于C-NSM(92%优 vs 75.6%优,P=0.046)。
- 两组NAC缺血坏死风险、总体并发症率和出血量无显著差异。
- R-NSM手术时间更长,总医疗费用显著更高(P<0.01)。
核心结论
- R-NSM临床结局与C-NSM相当,美学满意度更优,但手术时间更长、费用更高。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心病例对照研究,2011年7月至2019年9月,比较54例R-NSM与62例C-NSM联合即刻凝胶假体乳房再造。
主要发现
- R-NSM总体满意度92%优、8%良,C-NSM为75.6%优、24.4%良,P=0.046。
- R-NSM伤口/瘢痕相关患者报告美学结果优于C-NSM。
- 两组NAC缺血/坏死风险、总体并发症率和出血量无显著差异。
- R-NSM总医疗费用10,877±796美元,C-NSM为5,702±661美元,P<0.01。
临床怎么用
- 在追求美学满意度和瘢痕隐蔽时可考虑R-NSM,但需权衡更长手术时间与更高费用。
局限性
- 单中心病例对照设计,样本量有限(R-NSM 54例,C-NSM 62例),可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Robotic nipple sparing mastectomy (R-NSM), which uses the da Vinci surgical platform, could perform NSM and immediate breast reconstruction through a small and inconspicuous extra-mammary axillary or lateral chest incision. R-NSM was reported with extremely low nipple areolar complex (NAC) necrosis rate, good cosmetic results, and high patient satisfaction. However, there was little evidence available comparing the effectiveness and safety of R-NSM and conventional NSM (C-NSM) in the management of breast cancer. METHODS: A case control comparison study was conducted for patients with breast cancer who underwent R-NSM or C-NSM with immediate gel implant breast reconstruction (IGBR) from July 2011 to September 2019 at a single institution to compare the clinical outcomes, patient-reported esthetic results, and medical cost. RESULTS: According to the study design, 54 procedures of R-NSM were compared with 62 procedures of C-NSM in the surgical management of breast cancer combined with IGBR. Compared with C-NSM, R-NSM was associated with higher overall satisfaction (92% excellent and 8% good versus 75.6% excellent and 24.4% good, P = 0.046), and wound/scar related outcome in patient-reported esthetic results. The NAC ischemia/necrosis risk, overall complication rate, and blood loss were not significantly different between R-NSM and C-NSM groups. However, longer operation time and higher overall medical cost (10,877 ± 796 versus 5,702 ± 661 US Dollars, P<0.01) was observed in R-NSM group. CONCLUSION: Compared with C-NSM, R-NSM showed comparable clinical outcomes and favorable patients' satisfaction with the esthetic results, but at the price of longer operation time and higher cost.
引用
- Lai HW, Chen ST, Mok CW, et al. Robotic versus conventional nipple sparing mastectomy and immediate gel implant breast reconstruction in the management of breast cancer- A case control comparison study with analysis of clinical outcome, medical cost, and patient-reported cosmetic results. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2020. PMID: 32238306. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2020.02.021
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。