文献速递烧伤创面修复

烧伤创面感染报告指标缺乏统一:系统综述呼吁建立核心指标集

A systematic review of intervention studies demonstrates the need to develop a minimum set of indicators to report the presence of burn wound infection.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2020-04-24

该系统综述检索四个数据库,纳入72项报告烧伤创面感染结局的干预研究(71个独立数据集,52.1%为随机对照试验)。38.0%的研究未报告感染定义;有定义的研究中仅13.6%采用既往共识定义,指标使用从1种到9种不等(中位数3,四分位距2),最常见为创面存在细菌(61.0%)。作者认为定义缺失或不一致妨碍证据合成,需通过专家共识建立核心指标集。

要点

  • 报告烧伤创面感染结局的研究中,38.0%未说明感染定义。
  • 有定义的研究中仅13.6%采用既往共识定义,指标数量中位数3种。
  • 最常见指标为创面存在细菌,见于61.0%的研究。

核心结论

  • 报告烧伤创面感染结局的干预研究中,该结局常无定义或各研究定义不一,妨碍识别有效治疗的证据合成。
  • 因缺乏客观评估烧伤创面感染的方法,需专家共识确定所有相关试验应报告的最小指标集(核心指标集)。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索Ovid Medline、Ovid Embase、Cinahl、Cochrane Register of Trials四个数据库。
  • 共识别2056项研究,72项符合纳入标准,含71个独立数据集,52.1%为随机对照试验。
  • 数据系统提取并以叙述性方式报告。

主要发现

  • 59项(83.1%)在方法中计划测量该结局,其中44项(74.6%)描述了定义。
  • 44项中6项(13.6%)使用既往共识定义,41项(69.5%)描述具体指标。
  • 指标数量1种(11项,26.8%)至9种(2项,4.9%),中位数3,四分位距2。
  • 最常见指标为创面存在细菌(61.0%的研究);仅13项(31.7%)与其他研究使用相同指标。

关键数值与推荐

  • 计划测量烧伤创面感染的研究中,74.6%描述了定义,13.6%采用既往共识定义。
  • 定义所用指标数量中位数3(四分位距2),范围1至9种。
  • 创面存在细菌是最常用指标,占61.0%的研究。
  • 仅31.7%的研究与其他至少一项研究使用相同指标定义烧伤创面感染。

临床怎么用

  • 解读烧伤创面感染干预证据时,应关注各研究定义与指标是否一致,避免直接合并异质结局。
  • 设计或报告烧伤创面感染相关研究时,应明确报告所用定义及具体指标。
  • 临床参考相关证据时需注意定义缺失或不统一可能降低证据可靠性。

局限性

  • 原文摘要未报告检索时限、偏倚风险评估方法及研究间异质性的定量分析。
  • 原文摘要未报告各指标的具体判定阈值及研究地域、烧伤人群特征等细节。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: Burn wound infections result in delayed healing and increased pain, scarring, sepsis risk and healthcare costs. Clinical decision making about burn wound infection should be supported by evidence syntheses. Validity of evidence from systematic reviews may be reduced if definitions of burn wound infectionvary between trials. This review aimed to determine whether burn wound infectionis defined, and whether there is variation in the indicators used to define burn wound infectionacross studies testing interventions for patients with burns. METHOD: Searches were carried out in four databases (Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase, Cinahl, Cochrane Register of Trials) to identify studies evaluating interventions for patients with burns and reporting a burn wound infection outcome. Pre-defined inclusion and exclusion criteria were systematically applied to select relevant studies. Data were systematically extracted and reported narratively. RESULTS: 2056 studies were identified, of which 72 met the inclusion criteria, comprising 71 unique datasets. 52.1% of studies were randomised controlled trials. Twenty-eight (38.0%) studies reporting a burn wound infection outcome did not report how they had defined it. In the methods of included studies, 59 studies (83.1%) reported that they planned to measure burn wound infection as an outcome. Of these, 44 studies (74.6%) described how they had defined burn wound infection; 6 studies (13.6%) reported use of a previously developed consensus-informed definition of burn wound infection, and 41 studies (69.5%) described the specific indicators used to define it. Studies used between one (11 studies; 26.8%) and nine indicators (2 studies; 4.9%) to define burn wound infection (median = 3, inter-quartile range = 2). The most commonly used indicator was presence of bacteria in the wound (61.0% of studies). Only 13 studies (31.7%) defined burn wound infection using the same indicators as at least one other study. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS: Within intervention studies reporting burn wound infection outcomes, a definition of this outcome is commonly not provided, or it varies between studies. This will prevent evidence synthesis to identify effective treatments for patients with burn injuries. Since there is no objective method for assessing burn wound infection, expert consensus is needed to agree a minimum set of indicators (Core Indicator Set) reported in all trials reporting burn wound infection as an outcome.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Davies A, Spickett-Jones F, Jenkins ATA, et al. A systematic review of intervention studies demonstrates the need to develop a minimum set of indicators to report the presence of burn wound infection. Burns. 2020. PMID: 32340771. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2020.03.009

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。