更新烧伤中心转诊标准:2018年电子德尔菲共识研究结果
该研究通过61名专家参与的四轮电子德尔菲共识流程,修订了烧伤中心转诊标准。新标准强调对深二度及以上烧伤≥10%TBSA、全层烧伤≥5%TBSA等患者强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊,并提倡小面积烧伤尽早门诊随访及远程医疗应用。
要点
- 深二度及以上烧伤≥10%TBSA或全层烧伤≥5%TBSA强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊
- 儿童和老年人有特殊敷料或医疗需求者应转诊烧伤中心
- 电、化学、放射损伤及冻伤、SJS/TEN、坏死性软组织感染受益于烧伤中心治疗
核心结论
- 修订后的共识标准促进沟通,使分诊和治疗根据患者特征、损伤严重程度、地理和转诊机构能力个体化定制。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用迭代电子德尔菲共识流程,由n=61名烧伤利益相关者和专家组成多学科小组,经过四轮达成共识。
主要发现
- 深二度或更深烧伤≥10%TBSA、全层烧伤≥5%TBSA强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊。
- 儿童和老年人有特定敷料和医疗需求者,以及电、化学、放射损伤等特殊情况强烈推荐会诊。
- 小面积烧伤最好伤后尽快在烧伤中心门诊随访,最好不延迟一周或以上。
- 冻伤、Stevens-Johnson综合征/中毒性表皮坏死松解症和坏死性软组织感染患者受益于烧伤中心治疗。
- 远程医疗和技术解决方案可能有助于达到该标准。
关键数值与推荐
- 深二度或更深烧伤≥10%TBSA burned强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊。
- 全层烧伤≥5%TBSA burned强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊。
- 小面积烧伤门诊随访最好不延迟一周或以上。
临床怎么用
- 临床中依据修订标准对烧伤患者进行分诊,对符合指征者强烈推荐烧伤中心会诊。
- 小面积烧伤应尽早安排烧伤中心门诊随访,避免延迟一周以上。
- 利用远程医疗和技术解决方案促进烧伤中心与转诊机构的沟通和个体化治疗。
局限性
- 缺乏关于适当烧伤患者分诊的 compelling 临床试验数据。
- 现有标准使用中常出现烧伤面积和深度估计错误,导致过度或不足分诊。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Existing burn center referral criteria were developed several years ago, and subsequent innovations in burn care have occurred. Coupled with frequent errors in the estimation of extent of burn injury and depth by referring providers, patients are both over and under-triaged when the existing criteria are used to support patient care decisions. In the absence of compelling clinical trial data on appropriate burn patient triage, we convened a multidisciplinary panel of experts to execute an iterative eDelphi consensus process to facilitate a revision. The eDelphi process panel consisted of n = 61 burn stakeholders and experts and progressed through four rounds before reaching consensus on key clinical domains. The major findings are that 1) burn center consultation is strongly recommended for all patients with deep partial-thickness or deeper burns ≥ 10% TBSA burned, for full-thickness burns ≥ 5% TBSA burned, for children and older adults with specific dressing and medical needs, and for special burn circumstances including electrical, chemical, and radiation injuries; 2) smaller burns are ideally followed in burn center outpatient settings as soon as possible after injury, preferably without delays of a week or more; 3) frostbite, Stevens-Johnson syndrome/TENS, and necrotizing soft-tissue infection patients benefit from burn center treatment; and 4) telemedicine and technological solutions are of likely benefit in achieving this standard. Unlike the original criteria, the revised consensus-based guidelines create a framework promoting communication so that triage and treatment are specifically tailored to individual patient characteristics, injury severity, geography, and the capabilities of referring institutions.
引用
- Bettencourt AP, Romanowski KS, Joe V, et al. Updating the Burn Center Referral Criteria: Results From the 2018 eDelphi Consensus Study. J Burn Care Res. 2020. PMID: 32123911. doi:10.1093/jbcr/iraa038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。