三维表面成像系统在乳房体积估算中的准确性评估
成像仪估计与术中体积的Pearson相关系数为0.812,人体测量为0.848;成像仪平均差-233.5 cm,人体测量平均差-102.7 cm。对于600 cm及以下的乳房体积,两种方法均与术中体积接近,但大于600 cm时均倾向于低估真实体积,且按提供估计的整形外科医生或实施乳房切除术的乳腺外科医生分层并未消除该低估。
要点
- 对于600 cm及以下的乳房体积,Crisalix表面成像仪与有经验整形外科医生的人体测量估计及术中标本重量所测真实体积准确性接近。
- 成像仪估计与术中体积的Pearson相关系数为0.812,人体测量估计为0.848。
- 两种方法对大于600 cm的乳房均倾向于低估真实体积,且分层后低估仍存在。
核心结论
- 对于600 cm及以下的乳房体积,Crisalix表面成像仪的准确性接近有经验整形外科医生的人体测量估计和术中标本重量所测真实体积。
- 表面成像可能作为较小乳房患者手术规划和引导患者期望的辅助工具。
研究设计与样本
- 以术中乳房切除术标本重量为金标准,体积换算假设密度为0.958 g/cm。
主要发现
- 成像仪估计与术中体积的Pearson相关系数为0.812。
- 人体测量估计与术中体积的Pearson相关系数为0.848。
- 成像仪与术中体积的平均差为-233.5 cm,人体测量估计与术中体积的平均差为-102.7 cm。
- 按乳房体积分层,对于600 cm及以下的乳房体积,表面成像仪和人体测量估计均与术中体积密切匹配;对于大于600 cm的乳房,两种技术均倾向于低估真实体积。
- 按提供估计的整形外科医生或实施乳房切除术的乳腺外科医生分层并未消除较大乳房体积下的低估。
临床怎么用
- 对于600 cm及以下的乳房体积,可考虑使用Crisalix表面成像仪作为手术规划和引导患者期望的辅助工具。
- 对于大于600 cm的乳房体积,应意识到表面成像和人体测量估计均可能低估真实体积。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Preoperative prediction of breast volume can guide patient expectations and aid surgical planning in breast reconstruction. Here, we evaluate the accuracy of a portable surface imager (Crisalix S.A., Lausanne, Switzerland) in predicting breast volume compared with anthropomorphic estimates and intraoperative specimen weights. METHODS: Twenty-five patients (41 breasts) undergoing mastectomy were scanned preoperatively with the Crisalix surface imager, and 1 of 3 attending plastic surgeons provided an anthropomorphic volume estimate. Intraoperative mastectomy weights were used as the gold standard. Volume conversions were performed assuming a density of 0.958 g/cm. RESULTS: The Pearson correlation coefficient between imager estimates and intraoperative volumes was 0.812. The corresponding value for anthropomorphic estimates and intraoperative volumes was 0.848. The mean difference between imager and intraoperative volumes was -233.5 cm, whereas the mean difference between anthropomorphic estimates and intraoperative volumes was -102.7 cm. Stratifying by breast volume, both surface imager and anthropomorphic estimates closely matched intraoperative volumes for breast volumes 600 cm and less, but the 2 techniques tended to underestimate true volumes for breasts larger than 600 cm. Stratification by plastic surgeon providing the estimate and breast surgeon performing the mastectomy did not eliminate this underestimation at larger breast volumes. CONCLUSIONS: For breast volumes 600 cm and less, the accuracy of the Crisalix surface imager closely matches anthropomorphic estimates given by experienced plastic surgeons and true volumes as measured from intraoperative specimen weights. Surface imaging may potentially be useful as an adjunct in surgical planning and guiding patient expectations for patients with smaller breast sizes.
引用
- Kwong JW, Tijerina JD, Choi S, et al. Assessing the Accuracy of a 3-Dimensional Surface Imaging System in Breast Volume Estimation. Ann Plast Surg. 2020. PMID: 32032116. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002244
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。