将唇裂模拟训练纳入「集训营式」课程
结果显示模拟后唇裂修复多数方面的自评显著提高,94%(n=15)认为模拟比标准准备更有效,训练级别越高自评与唇部对称性越好。
要点
- 模拟器操作后唇裂修复多数方面自评显著提高,单纯授课后提高有限
- 94%(n=15)认为模拟远优于标准准备,且应列为必修
- 训练级别越高,自评分数与唇部对称性测量越好
核心结论
- 该试点课程展示了将成人学习理论融入整形外科培训、用高保真模拟器刻意练习唇裂修复的可行路径。
- 模拟训练较单纯授课更能提升唇裂修复相关自评,且各训练级别均认可其价值。
研究设计与样本
- 作者基于成人学习理论原则创建「集训营式」唇裂课程,并试点高保真手术训练器以允许受训者操作自主。
- 每环节前后行自评调查,课程结束行自信心调查,并评估唇/鼻对称性的人体测量指标。
主要发现
- 授课后自评知识/技能提升甚微,模拟后唇裂修复多数方面显著提高。
- 整个课程带来的自评提升最大,自评各方面差异均显著。
- 训练级别较高者自评分数更高、唇部对称性更好。
- 94%(n=15)认为模拟比标准准备单独使用有效得多,所有参与者均强烈同意模拟有助于主动学习并应列为必修。
临床怎么用
- 可在整形外科住院医师培训中采用「授课+视频+高保真模拟器即时操作」的小班课程结构。
- 将模拟训练作为唇裂修复技能训练的必修环节,并按训练级别分层安排。
局限性
- 作者指出仍需进一步评估该教学模式能否加速唇裂修复及其他手术复杂技能组合的获得。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The traditions of surgical education have changed little over the years. However, the increasing focus on patient safety and duty hour restrictions mandates that residents start developing complex skill sets earlier to ensure they graduate with procedural competency. Surgical training is poised to exploit high-fidelity simulation technology to mitigate these pressures. METHODS: By revisiting principles of adult learning theory, the authors created a "bootcamp-style" cleft lip curriculum that sought to (1) maximize educational impact and (2) pilot a high-fidelity procedural trainer permitting resident operative autonomy as part of that curriculum. Trainees participated in small group educational sessions comprised of a standard cleft didactic lecture, augmented by instructional video. Participants immediately processed knowledge from the lecture/video by "operating" on the simulator, allowing opportunities for questions and self-reflection, completing the learning cycle. A self-assessment survey was taken before and after each component of the session, including a self-confidence survey to conclude the session. Anthropometric measures of lip/nasal symmetry were assessed. RESULTS: Sixteen trainees participated in the program. Little increase in self-assessed knowledge/skill was seen after the lecture, but significant increases in most aspects of cleft lip repair were seen after simulation. The greatest increase in self-assessment was seen for the program as a whole, with significant differences across all aspects of the self-assessment. Higher levels of training were associated with both higher self-assessment scores and better lip symmetry. Regardless of level of training, all participants strongly agreed that simulation helped them actively engage in learning and should be a required aspect of training, whereas 94% (n = 15) thought simulation was much more effective than standard preparation alone. CONCLUSIONS: This pilot curriculum illustrates a mechanism to incorporate lessons from adult learning theory into plastic surgery training using a high-fidelity simulator for deliberate practice of cleft lip repair. Further evaluation is warranted to determine whether this didactic model can accelerate the acquisition of the complex skill set required for cleft lip repair and other surgical procedures.
引用
- Saldanha FYL, Loan GJ, Calabrese CE, et al. Incorporating Cleft Lip Simulation Into a "Bootcamp-Style" Curriculum. Ann Plast Surg. 2021. PMID: 32049760. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002265
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。