YouTube美容手术视频信息质量评估
该研究于2016年5-6月检索YouTube上12种最常见美容手术视频,用改良EQIP标准评分前25个结果。共523个视频平均分13.1/27,仅3个搜索词达高质量标准,医生作者视频评分高于患者。结论:美容手术视频信息质量低,患者需警惕不准确信息,医生应制作高质量教育视频。
要点
- YouTube美容手术视频整体信息质量偏低,平均EQIP仅13.1/27
- 21个搜索词中仅3个达到高质量视频标准
- 医生作者视频评分高于患者作者视频,但仅占59%
核心结论
- YouTube上美容手术视频信息质量低,患者需意识到信息可能不准确,整形医生应制作高质量视频教育患者。
研究设计与样本
- 于2016年5-6月检索YouTube上12种最常见美容手术视频,每个搜索词取前25个结果,共523个视频(排除重复后)用改良EQIP标准评分。
主要发现
- 所有视频平均改良EQIP评分为13.1(SE 0.18),满分27。
- 「nose reshaping」搜索词平均分最低为10.24(SE 0.74),「breast augmentation」最高为15.96(SE 0.65)。
- 医生作者视频占59%,其平均EQIP评分高于患者作者视频。
- 21个搜索词中仅3个的平均改良EQIP评分达到高质量视频标准。
关键数值与推荐
- 改良EQIP标准基于视频结构、内容和作者身份进行评分,满分27。
- 高质量视频标准未在原文摘要中给出具体阈值。
临床怎么用
- 整形医生应主动制作高质量的美容手术教育视频,以对抗YouTube上的低质量信息。
- 临床沟通中应提醒患者谨慎对待网络视频信息,避免被误导。
局限性
- 检索时间为2016年5-6月,结果可能随时间变化。
- 仅评估前25个搜索结果,未覆盖全部视频。
- 原文摘要未报告评分者间一致性等细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Videos on YouTube can be posted without regulation or content oversight. Unfortunately, many patients use YouTube as a resource on aesthetic surgery, leading to misinformation. Currently, there are no objective assessments of the quality of information on YouTube about aesthetic surgery. METHODS: YouTube was queried for videos about the 12 most common aesthetic surgical procedures, identified from the 2015 American Society of Plastic Surgeons procedural statistics between May and June of 2016. The top 25 results for each search term were scored using the modified Ensuring Quality Information for Patients criteria based on video structure, content, and author identification. Average Ensuring Quality Information for Patients score, view count, and video duration were compared between authorship groups. RESULTS: A total of 523 videos were graded after excluding duplicates. The mean modified Ensuring Quality Information for Patients score for all videos was 13.1 (SE, 0.18) of a possible 27. The videos under the search "nose reshaping" had the lowest mean score of 10.24 (SE, 0.74), whereas "breast augmentation" had the highest score of 15.96 (SE, 0.65). Physician authorship accounted for 59 percent of included videos and had a higher mean Ensuring Quality Information for Patients score than those by patients. Only three of the 21 search terms had a mean modified Ensuring Quality Information for Patients score meeting criteria for high-quality videos. CONCLUSIONS: The information contained in aesthetic surgery videos on YouTube is low quality. Patients should be aware that the information has the potential to be inaccurate. Plastic surgeons should be encouraged to develop high-quality videos to educate patients.
引用
- Gray MC, Gemmiti A, Ata A, et al. Can You Trust What You Watch? An Assessment of the Quality of Information in Aesthetic Surgery Videos on YouTube. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2020. PMID: 31985630. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000006463
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。