文献速递美容整形乳房整形与再造创面修复

整形外科受训者手术自主性调查

Trainee Operative Autonomy in Plastic Surgery.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2020-01-01

该研究采用基于Zwisch分级的手术自主性平行问卷,调查了28个项目点的受训者和35个项目点的教师,评估17项核心整形手术的自主性。结果显示,毕业年级受训者在乳房组织扩张器再造和腕管松解中独立性最高,在面部提升和鼻整形中最低;教师对受训者自主性的评价在82%的手术中高于受训者自评。

要点

  • 毕业年级受训者平均仅40%在受调查手术中达到仅监督级自主性。
  • 鼻整形手术无毕业年级受训者达到仅监督级自主性。
  • 教师对82%受调查手术的受训者自主性评价高于受训者自评。

核心结论

  • 整形外科受训者总体认可逐步获得手术自主性,但多数毕业年级受训者在多数核心手术中未达到仅监督级独立性。
  • 教师对多数手术的受训者自主性评价高于受训者自评。
  • 病例记录方式在受训者之间及受训者与教师之间存在不一致,标准化可能改善自主性的进展与评估。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用基于Zwisch渐进手术自主性量表的平行问卷,电子分发给所有认证培训项目的受训者和教师。
  • 受训者被询问17项核心整形手术的自主性、病例记录方式及进入独立实践的感知准备度。
  • 教师使用相同指标评估其毕业年级受训者。

主要发现

  • 28个项目的受训者和35个项目的教师参与。
  • 毕业年级受训者报告乳房组织扩张器再造和腕管松解的手术独立性最高,面部提升和鼻整形最低。
  • 毕业年级受训者平均40%在受调查手术中达到仅监督级自主性,鼻整形无一人达到。
  • 教师认为毕业年级受训者手术自主性最高的是肉毒毒素注射和烧伤切除与移植,最低的是鼻整形、唇裂修复和面部提升。
  • 教师对82%受调查手术的毕业年级受训者自主性评价高于受训者自评。

临床怎么用

  • 应关注毕业年级受训者在鼻整形、面部提升等手术中自主性不足的问题。
  • 教师评估与受训者自评存在差异,需加强沟通和标准化评估。
  • 统一病例记录方式有助于跟踪手术自主性进展。

局限性

  • 研究为问卷调查,可能存在回复偏倚。
  • 参与项目数量有限,结果外推需谨慎。
  • 未报告问卷效度验证细节。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Appropriate, progressive trainee autonomy is critical for training competent plastic surgeons who are adequately prepared to enter independent practice. Evaluation and reporting of meaningful operative autonomy among trainees in plastic surgery are understudied. METHODS: Parallel survey instruments were developed using the Zwisch metric for progressive operative autonomy and distributed electronically to trainees and faculties in all accredited training programs. Trainees were queried about their operative autonomy in 17 core plastic surgery procedures, associated approach to logging cases, and perceived readiness to enter practice. Faculties provided assessment of their final-year trainees using the same metrics. RESULTS: Trainees in 28 programs and faculties in 35 programs participated. Final-year trainees reported the most operative independence with breast tissue expander reconstruction and carpal tunnel release and the least with facelift and rhinoplasty. A mean of 40% of final-year trainees reached supervision only autonomy in the procedures queried; none achieved this with rhinoplasty. Faculties identified the highest final-year trainee operative autonomy with botulinum toxin injection and burn excision and grafting; the least trainee independence was reported with rhinoplasty, cleft lip repair, and facelift. Faculty perception of final-year trainee autonomy was higher than that of trainees for 82% of procedures queried. CONCLUSIONS: Although plastic surgery trainees endorse gradual operative autonomy overall, a majority of final-year trainees do not perceive supervision only independence in the majority of core procedures queried. Faculties perceive higher trainee operative autonomy than trainees for most procedures. Discordant approaches to case logging were identified both among trainees and between trainees and faculties. Standardization may improve both progression and assessment of operative autonomy in plastic surgery training.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Vargas CR, Long TC, Kumar AR, et al. Trainee Operative Autonomy in Plastic Surgery. Ann Plast Surg. 2020. PMID: 31913904. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002210

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。