文献速递颅颌面外科瘢痕与激光

单侧唇裂修复:两种术式术后唇鼻瘢痕的定量评估

Unilateral Cleft Lip Repair: A Quantitative Scale Assessment of Postoperative Lip and Nose Scars Across 2 Operative Techniques.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2019-01-01

本研究采用3种经验证的瘢痕评估量表,由5名独立评估者回顾性评价58例单侧唇裂修复患者(36例extended Mohler,22例Millard)的术后唇鼻瘢痕。结果显示两种术式在唇瘢痕和鼻瘢痕评分上均无统计学显著差异,唇瘢痕评估者间信度优秀,鼻瘢痕为中等。

要点

  • extended Mohler与Millard术式在唇裂术后唇、鼻瘢痕评分上无显著差异。
  • 唇瘢痕评估者间信度优秀(ICC 0.850–0.913),鼻瘢痕为中等(ICC 0.565–0.714)。
  • 3种瘢痕量表(MSS、MSRS、SBES)均可用于唇裂术后瘢痕定量评价。

核心结论

  • 采用3种经验证的瘢痕评估量表,extended Mohler与Millard两种单侧唇裂修复术式在唇瘢痕和鼻瘢痕上均无统计学显著差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入58例连续单侧唇裂修复患者(36例extended Mohler,22例Millard),共评估116张术后正面和基底位照片。
  • 由5名独立评估者使用MSS、MSRS和SBES三种量表分别对唇瘢痕和鼻瘢痕评分,采用组内相关系数(ICC)评估评估者间信度。

主要发现

  • 唇瘢痕评估者间信度优秀:MSS ICC 0.903(0.857-0.938),MSRS ICC 0.913(0.872-0.944),SBES ICC 0.850(0.775-0.902)。
  • 鼻瘢痕评估者间信度中等:MSS ICC 0.714(0.579-0.816),MSRS ICC 0.693(0.548-0.802),SBES ICC 0.565(0.359-0.720)。
  • 唇瘢痕评分两组比较:MSS 6.983±1.469 vs 6.772±1.175(P=0.571);MSRS 5.433±1.530 vs 5.481±1.290(P=0.902);SBES 3.633±0.977 vs 3.446±0.995(P=0.483)。
  • 鼻瘢痕评分两组比较:MSS 5.644±1.131 vs 5.491±0.689(P=0.523);MSRS 4.233±0.987 vs 3.991±0.705(P=0.320);SBES 3.933±0.750 vs 4.018±0.486(P=0.603)。

临床怎么用

  • 对于单侧唇裂修复,extended Mohler与Millard术式在瘢痕结局上无显著差异,术式选择可基于其他临床因素综合考虑。
  • 唇瘢痕可采用MSS、MSRS或SBES进行可靠定量评估;鼻瘢痕评估信度中等,需谨慎解读或结合其他方法。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究设计,样本量有限(58例),可能影响统计效能。
  • 仅评估术后照片,未纳入患者主观感受或长期随访数据。
  • 鼻瘢痕评估者间信度仅为中等,可能影响结果稳定性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: There is no quantitative evidence supporting one unilateral cleft lip (UCL) repair technique over the other with regard to scarring. We sought to evaluate the difference between the extended Mohler and Millard techniques, using 3 scar assessment scales. METHODS: Postoperative frontal and basal photographs of patients undergoing UCL repair were reviewed. Three validated scar assessment scales were used: the Manchester Scar Scale (MSS), modified scar-rating scale (MSRS), and Stony Brook Scar Evaluation Scale. Lip and nose scars were rated by 5 independent raters using each of the scales. Interrater reliability was assessed using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC). RESULTS: Assessment of 116 images for 58 consecutive patients undergoing UCL repair (36 extended Mohler, 22 Millard) was performed. Interrater reliability was excellent for lip scars (ICCs, 0.903 [0.857-0.938] for MSS, 0.913 [0.872-0.944] for MSRS, and 0.850 [0.775-0.902] for SBES) and moderate for nose scar assessment (ICCs, 0.714 [0.579-0.816] for MSS, 0.693 [0.548-0.802] for MSRS, and 0.565 [0.359-0.720] for SBES). No statistically significant difference was found between the extended Mohler and Millard repairs in mean lip scar scores (MSS, 6.983 ± 1.469 vs 6.772 ± 1.175, P = 0.571; MSRS, 5.433 ± 1.530 vs 5.481 ± 1.290, P = 0.902; SBES, 3.633 ± 0.977 vs 3.446 ± 0.995, P = 0.483) or nose scar scores (MSS, 5.644 ± 1.131 vs 5.491 ± 0.689, P = 0.523; MSRS, 4.233 ± 0.987 vs 3.991 ± 0.705, P = 0.320; SBES, 3.933 ± 0.750 vs 4.018 ± 0.486, P = 0.603). CONCLUSIONS: Using 3 validated scar assessment scales, no significant difference was found between the extended Mohler and Millard techniques in terms of lip or nose scars.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ramly EP, Eisemann BS, Kantar RS, et al. Unilateral Cleft Lip Repair: A Quantitative Scale Assessment of Postoperative Lip and Nose Scars Across 2 Operative Techniques. Ann Plast Surg. 2019. PMID: 31688100. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000001991

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。