整形外科期刊中的引用偏倚:期刊影响因子能否预测单篇论文引用率?
该研究检索整形与重建外科领域全部期刊,统计2016至2017年发表论文在2018年的被引次数。共纳入33种期刊、9823篇论文,引用分布呈右偏,多数论文被引0或1次;仅34%论文达到或超过期刊影响因子(JIF),且JIF与单篇引用仅弱正相关,提示JIF不宜用于评价单篇论文。
要点
- 整形外科期刊存在引用偏倚,多数论文被引0或1次。
- 仅34%论文引用率达到或超过其期刊JIF。
- JIF与单篇论文引用率仅弱正相关,不宜评价单篇成果。
核心结论
- 整形外科期刊存在引用偏倚,与其它生物医学领域类似。
- 多数论文引用率未达到其期刊JIF,少数论文对引用和JIF有不 proportionate 影响。
- JIF不应用于评估单篇科学工作的质量和影响力。
研究设计与样本
- 通过Journal Citation Reports识别整形与重建外科领域全部期刊。
- 纳入2016年和2017年发表的全部单篇论文,统计其2018年被引次数。
- 共识别33种整形外科期刊,发表9823篇论文。
主要发现
- 引用分布呈右偏,多数论文被引0次(40%)或1次(25%)。
- 3374篇(34%)论文引用率达到或超过其期刊JIF,66%论文未达到。
- 综述类论文引用率(中位数2)高于原创论文(中位数1)(P < 0.0001)。
- 50%的论文贡献了93.7%的引用,12.6%的论文贡献了50%的引用。
- 引用数与JIF呈弱正相关(r = 0.327,P < 0.0001)。
临床怎么用
- 在学术评价中避免以JIF替代单篇论文的实际引用表现。
- 阅读整形外科文献时需注意期刊内引用分布高度偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Citation skew refers to the unequal distribution of citations to articles published in a particular journal. OBJECTIVES: We aimed to assess whether citation skew exists within plastic surgery journals and to determine whether the journal impact factor (JIF) is an accurate indicator of the citation rates of individual articles. METHODS: We used Journal Citation Reports to identify all journals within the field of plastic and reconstructive surgery. The number of citations in 2018 for all individual articles published in 2016 and 2017 was abstracted. RESULTS: Thirty-three plastic surgery journals were identified, publishing 9823 articles. The citation distribution showed right skew, with the majority of articles having either 0 or 1 citation (40% and 25%, respectively). A total of 3374 (34%) articles achieved citation rates similar to or higher than their journal's IF, whereas 66% of articles failed to achieve a citation rate equal to the JIF. Review articles achieved higher citation rates (median, 2) than original articles (median, 1) (P < 0.0001). Overall, 50% of articles contributed to 93.7% of citations and 12.6% of articles contributed to 50% of citations. A weak positive correlation was found between the number of citations and the JIF (r = 0.327, P < 0.0001). CONCLUSIONS: Citation skew exists within plastic surgery journals as in other fields of biomedical science. Most articles did not achieve citation rates equal to the JIF with a small percentage of articles having a disproportionate influence on citations and the JIF. Therefore, the JIF should not be used to assess the quality and impact of individual scientific work.
引用
- Asaad M, Kallarackal AP, Meaike J, et al. Citation Skew in Plastic Surgery Journals: Does the Journal Impact Factor Predict Individual Article Citation Rate? Aesthet Surg J. 2020. PMID: 31745562. doi:10.1093/asj/sjz336
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。