整形外科社交媒体影响者:伦理考量与文献综述
本文通过MEDLINE检索(截至2019年6月15日)并筛选26篇文献,分析社交媒体在整形外科中推广与赞助的伦理问题。基于医学伦理四原则,指出现有同行评议文献未专门讨论相关限制,强调整形外科医生在专业使用社交媒体前需认识其利弊。
要点
- 社交媒体在整形外科中常用于商业推广,但使用不当可引发伦理困境。
- 截至2019年6月,尚无同行评议文献专门讨论社交媒体赞助与推广的伦理限制。
- 整形外科医生在将社交媒体融入专业实践前,应认知其正面与负面效应。
核心结论
- 社交媒体在整形外科中的应用日益增多,其赞助与推广的伦理影响尚未被充分理解,且截至文献检索时无同行评议文章专门讨论相关限制。
研究设计与样本
- 文献综述:于2019年6月15日进行MEDLINE检索(自定义出版日期范围),初检获得139篇文献,最终选取26篇出版物进行分析。
主要发现
- 纳入分析的26篇文章来源:Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery(n=12)、Aesthetic Surgery Journal(n=8)、PRS Global Open(n=2)、Annals of Plastic Surgery(n=1)、BMJ(n=1)、AMA Journal of Ethics(n=1)、Facial Plastic Surgery(n=1)。
- 从医学伦理四原则角度分析了整形外科中的推广与赞助问题。
临床怎么用
- 整形外科医生在将社交媒体整合到专业生活前,应同时了解其积极和消极方面。
- 需关注社交媒体赞助与推广可能带来的伦理困境,推动未来相关讨论。
局限性
- 截至2019年6月15日检索,尚无同行评议文章专门讨论社交媒体在整形外科中赞助与推广的伦理限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Social media use has become a relevant tool in plastic surgery. These platforms are utilized for many reasons, such as business promotion. Although beneficial, social media can cause ethical dilemmas if used incorrectly. OBJECTIVES: A review of the literature revealed what is understood about the implications of social media in regards to sponsorship/promotion. This paper aimed to create the foundation surrounding this topic and help facilitate future discussions on this new ethical dilemma. METHODS: A MEDLINE search with a custom publication date range and a review of the literature was conducted on June 15, 2019. RESULTS: The search yielded 139 articles and abstracts. After review, 26 publications were chosen for analysis. Articles were taken from the following journals: Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (n = 12), Aesthetic Surgery Journal (n = 8), PRS Global Open (n = 2), Annals of Plastic Surgery (n = 1), BMJ (n = 1), AMA Journal of Ethics (n = 1), and Facial Plastic Surgery (n = 1). The 4 principles of medical ethics were analyzed in respect to promotion and sponsorship in plastic surgery. CONCLUSIONS: Social media is a novel platform that is becoming increasingly utilized in plastic surgery. Although its impact can be beneficial, it is not well understood in the context of social media sponsorship and promotion. To date, no peer-reviewed articles specifically discuss these limitations. It is critical that all plastic surgeons be cognizant of both the positive and negative aspects of social media before integrating it into their professional lives.
引用
- Gupta N, Dorfman R, Saadat S, et al. The Plastic Surgery Social Media Influencer: Ethical Considerations and a Literature Review. Aesthet Surg J. 2020. PMID: 31738821. doi:10.1093/asj/sjz329
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。